Does a house of foam stand up to flying projectiles better than a house of wood? Yes, but not as well as a house of laminated glass, according to recent research from Building Science Corporation in Westford, Mass. Foam sheathing can boost a house’s energy performance, but many builders worry about foam’s ability to resist projectiles during storms. A team of engineers tested the impact resistance of walls built with foam sheathing in place of plywood or oriented strand board (OSB). To test a foam-sheathed wall’s impact resistance, the team from Building Science shot 2x4s out of an air cannon at different wall assemblies using the standard impact test for hurricane glass: the ability to withstand an 8-ft. 2×4 shot with a muzzle velocity of 34 mph, or 50 ft. per second (fps).The engineers used four wall systems, all framed with 2x6s at 24 in. on center and clad with fiber-cement siding over housewrap. The standard wall had 7/16-in. OSB sheathing; the others used OSB or rigid-foam sheathing and spray foam in different combinations.

The best-scoring wall (1-in. foam sheathing outside and 2 in. of closed-cell spray foam between the studs) withstood a 2×4 at 43 fps—that is, the 2×4 broke through the fibercement siding, but bounced off without penetrating the foam sheathing. The standard wall with 7/16-in. OSB couldn’t withstand the force of the flying 2×4.
 

But neither wall met the hurricane-resistant window standard. To meet the 50-fps window standard, the team sheathed the wall with both OSB and foam, adding 2 in. of closed-cell spray foam between the studs.

Does this mean that in a hurricane, you’re safer standing in front of a window rather than a wall? “No,” says Peter Baker, an engineer with Building Science, “because walls do not shatter.” For more on this test, as well as videos, go to www.buildingscience.com/impact.

Photos: Courtesy of Building Science Corporation

Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

100-ft. Tape Measure

Laying out mudsills and foundations for new homes and additions requires a bigger tape measure than your everyday carry.

Buy at Amazon

Staple Gun

Although powered staplers are very popular, you still need a manual stapler on the job site. This staple gun from DEWALT® is reliable and easy to fire, reducing fatigue over prolonged use.

Buy at Amazon

Loctite Foamboard Adhesive

When foam board installations require an adhesive, it’s important to use compatible products like this adhesive from Loctite.

Buy at Amazon