FHB Logo Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter X Instagram Tiktok YouTube Plus Icon Close Icon Navigation Search Icon Navigation Search Icon Arrow Down Icon Video Guide Icon Article Guide Icon Modal Close Icon Guide Search Icon Skip to content
Subscribe
Log In
  • How-To
  • Design
  • Tools & Materials
  • Restoration
  • Videos
  • Blogs
  • Forum
  • Magazine
  • Members
  • FHB House
  • Podcast
Log In
How-To

Reader Feedback: Issue 141, August/September 2001

Issue 141
  • X
  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • pinterest
  • email
  • add to favorites Log in or Sign up to save your favorite articles

Debating the value of an expensive roof

In explaining his decision to use clay tile for his roof (FHB #139, pp. 96-101), David D. Quillin asserts that the wind where he lives can “peel regular asphalt shingles off a roof as if they are paper.” My brothers and I built our parents’ house about 5 miles east of his in 1980. My mother still lives in that house on Fenwick Island, a sliver of land a half-mile wide that separates the Assawoman Bay from the Atlantic Ocean. Contrary to Mr. Quillin’s assertion, the asphalt shingles we used have held fast. In the 21 years since we installed that roof, my mother has fled inland several times as dangerous storms have approached. But she hasn’t lost a shingle; nor has any one of her neighbors.

Mr. Quillin also maintains that the price of his tile roof—$750 per square—“will be a bargain … if the material does last a lifetime.” How long does he expect to live? The materials for a 25-year shingle roof are about $30 per square. If you add $50 per square for installation (a figure that is too high for most asphalt roofs and far too low for a tile roof), the 25-year shingle roof would cost $80 per square as opposed to $800 per square for the tile roof. Because Mr. Quillin’s roof cost 10 times as much as an asphalt roof, his tile roof would have to last 10 times as long—250 years—to begin to be a bargain.

If Mr. Quillin’s 2800-sq. ft. house required about 32 squares of shingles, the cost of his roof would be in the neighborhood of $25,600. Had he used asphalt shingles, it would have been about $2,560. Like many other contributors to FHB, Mr. Quillin attempts to justify the steep price of his handsome roof by denigrating the performance of asphalt shingles. The truth is that asphalt shingles perform extremely well on the Eastern Shore of Maryland, and they are the overwhelming choice of material for builders and homeowners in that area (and just about every other area in the country). Some people, including David Quillin, don’t like the way asphalt shingles look, and they are willing to pay a premium for a more attractive material. That’s fine, but they should just say so.

—John Carroll, Durham, NC

David D. Quillin replies: Mr. Carroll states that he built his mother’s home in the same area as my home 21 years ago and that the roof has withstood the forces of nature just fine. I don’t dispute this fact, but I would point out that this area has had no severe northeasters or hurricanes in that time period. Although the mid-Atlantic area historically was hit by a severe hurricane every ten years or so, we have gone nearly 40 years now without a direct hit. This does not mean the big storms aren’t coming, and when they do come, the flimsier, lighter materials currently popular will come in for re-evaluation.

Second, Mr. Carroll states that the shingles that I used will be a bargain only if I live to be 250 years old. Well, maybe I’m planning on it. Actually, the numbers he uses to make that argument are a little high, but not too far off. I would respond in two ways. First, if a hurricane rips off the roof of his mother’s house, it would be difficult to see what kind of a bargain he considered the asphalt shingles. Second, part of the value of the clay shingles that I used is not just their own structural integrity but also the strength that they add to the entire house as part of an overall strategy of weighting the house down to resist wind uplift.

Finally, Mr. Carroll says that I am using the shingles because they are attractive, and I ought just to say so. I did say so, quite clearly, in the article. I was looking for a shingle to satisfy a number of requirements, top of the list being attractiveness. Also on the list was structural soundness in the face of hurricane-force winds.

I think that asphalt shingles are a good choice for roofing in many situations, and I have specified them on several projects that I have worked on. Their chief virtue is their low cost. I do not think that they are especially attractive, and I doubt many people would use them if they were not so inexpensive. What I like the least about asphalt shingles is that they are not especially durable (40-year and 50-year warranties notwithstanding), and so consequently they become just another “disposable” consumer item that will be taking up space in landfills.

For now, homeowners don’t have many choices when looking for affordable roofing materials, so asphalt shingles play a significant role in the housing market. That doesn’t mean that we should consider them ideal and be blind to their limitations.

About the pressure at the bottom of a dam

Congratulations on your most excellent  June/July 2001 issue. I especially enjoyed the article “A Stair in the Air” (FHB #140, pp. 70-73). Although I might occasionally lapse into this degree of compulsive infatuation with an idea, I wouldn’t have tackled this one. A stair this open would guarantee that my wife would never again visit the second floor.

In “Hang Ten” (“Great Moments in Building History,” p. 146), Paul E. Mitchell notes “… I wish I had remembered a basic physics principle I learned in college: The pressure at the bottom of a dam is proportional to the height of the dam squared.” Sorry, Paul. The pressure is proportional to the height, not the height squared. What college was that?

—Larry Sher, Naples, NY

Precautions for heavy snow

After 17 years in Tahoe, I finally had enough snow shoveling, blowing and plowing to fill my memory bank with a whiteout; I moved to a snowless part of California. Ed Trembly’s plowing ideas (FHB #139, “Commentary,” pp. 16, 18) are a good primer for medium snowfall areas. Big—I mean huge, deep and dangerous—snowfalls are a whole different story. The drawing of the New England house and garage is cute, but illegal to build in a heavy-snow area. The snow discharge from the garage roof could easily total the car and its passengers. The drop distance from the second story of the house to the front door would also kill someone entering or leaving the house. Typical snow-load designs for the Tahoe area are 185 lb. to 220 lb. per sq. ft. Many winters, the actual load has been double that. Structures collapse from the weight of the snow and ice. Pets and people are hit, trapped or killed by the “white death.” Chimneys, vent pipes, crickets, antennas, decks and rails are wiped off houses. Windows will be blocked for an entire winter, and the weight on the house may compress walls so that sliders or hinged doors won’t move until spring.

A completely different thought process is needed if you build in heavy-snow country. Outside: Do all the items that Ed suggested, and place high snow poles near fences, curbs and valued plants. When there is 4 ft. to 6 ft. or more snow from a single storm, the snow-plow driver can’t see what is there, so don’t use PVC snow poles that are the same color as the snow. Valuable shrubs and trees should be kept away from the discharge zone because they will be smashed by thousands of pounds of crashing snow and ice. Think of the snow’s discharge path, and place garage doors at the gable end of the garage so that you won’t get trapped in or out of the garage. The same is true for exterior doors; they should be at a gable end or have a well-engineered cricket over the door.

If a roof discharges its snow load onto a deck, then it will have to be designed to hold the original deck’s snow load in addition to the discharged roof load.

Add in wind (drifting snow), the sun (melting the snow unevenly from one side of the house to the other), earthquakes (with a huge weight on the roof), and you better find a good local engineer and architect who are familiar with snow problems.

—Ken Menzer, Auburn, CA

Senco’s nail gun works well on cement siding

I appreciated John La Torre’s timely article “Working With Fiber-Cement Siding” (FHB #140, pp. 104-109), but I wanted to add a comment about nailing. I have used the Senco nail gun (SN 65) quite a bit on cement siding, and this gun makes it easy to set the nail depth so that nails drive in just right (flush) every time that you pull the trigger.

The nailing system on this nail gun has what Senco calls a “restrictive trigger.” What this means is that it is a single shot and not a bounce gun. To fire it, you depress the nosepiece and then pull the trigger. It fires one nail and won’t fire again until you repeat the operation. A different trigger can be installed that allows you to use this gun as a bounce nailer. I hear that Senco’s latest version has a microchip that allows you to bounce or single-shot nail without changing triggers.

—Larry Haun, Coos Bay, OR

The housewrap debate continues

I’m glad to see that Joseph Lstiburek isn’t willing to knuckle under to the spin doctor from DuPont (FHB #140, “Letters,” p. 6). The way I see it, building paper is for waterproofing. I use 15-lb. tar paper and double it on the corners. I don’t really worry about air infiltration through the walls. We always use full plywood sheathing, and I have yet to blow air through a piece of plywood.

And how does Tyvek seal the nail holes? Tar paper leaves a residue on the nail as it passes through that helps to seal the paper to the shank of the nail.

I haven’t had a callback for a sidewall leak in my 25 years of building, and I won’t switch to a more expensive product that is of dubious value to my clients.

— Kurt Housh, via e-mail

Joseph Lstiburek, in his letter (FHB #140, p. 6), disputes the effectiveness of Tyvek for reducing air infiltration. Although Lstiburek demonstrates that he does understand the principles of air leakage and has successfully built tighter houses, his letter demonstrates nothing about the effectiveness or lack of effectiveness of Tyvek.

The only way to do a proper controlled study of the effectiveness of Tyvek is in the manner described by Todd Apple of DuPont Tyvek Weatherization Systems in the same FHB issue. The study described by Apple employed two identical houses built in the same climate, tested in identical manners, one using Tyvek, the other not. The results of such a study are based on sound, scientific procedure.

All that Lstiburek can honestly say is that he is able to reach a certain standard of air tightness without using Tyvek housewrap. Good for him.

—Tim Murphy, Canmore, AB, Canada

Don’t rely on toenails at the rafter-to-plate connection

Mike Guertin’s response to the question from Jake O’Brien (FHB #140, “Q&A,” p. 20) on how to resist rafter thrust when the joists are perpendicular to the rafters contains at least one pitfall. He suggests building a diaphragm floor in the attic to take the tension forces induced by the rafter thrust. Although there is plenty of tension-resisting capacity in such a floor system, a weak point in this scheme could be the connection between the rafter and the plate.

Scaling your drawing (for the sake of argument), a building of about 19 ft. in width with hemlock-fir rafters 24 in. o. c. at a 12-in-12 pitch under a snow load of, say, 40 psf will develop a horizontal rafter thrust of something like 530 lb. at each rafter tail. If the carpenter uses 16d nails and toenails the seat cut of the rafter into the plate (and every nail is perfectly placed), each fastener can carry only about 70 lb. of load. At least eight nails would be needed to resist the calculated thrust. It is unlikely that such a nailed connection could be made without splitting the seat of the rafter.

It would probably be better to engineer some kind of steel-strap connection between the rafter and the floor diaphragm to resist the thrust.

—Carl Mezoff, Stamford, CT

Basement drains breed mold

Thank you for the great article by Larry Janesky, “Keeping a Basement Dry” (FHB #140, pp. 64-69). I would like to add a caution, however.

The one drawback to the interior-drainage correction practiced by many contractors is the wall/footing joint drainage flashing. Several types of plastic cove flashing are available and used with interior drain-tile replacement. Some contractors use a piece of cedar beveled siding to keep a space at the wall and then remove the siding after finishing the cement.

Concrete-block walls have holes drilled into each core at the top of the footing to allow water to leak out and down to the interior-drain tile. If the floor is not removed in cases where there are no drain tiles, a plastic cove base is glued to the floor to capture water seepage and conduct it to a new sump pit installed by the contractor.

Here’s the caution: These coves are breeding ground for mold and bacteria. People with asthma or other sensitivities to airborn allergens often have to leave the house due to the toxic reaction they experience when the spores circulate in the air in the house. The blower in the furnace or air conditioner picks up the irritant and distributes it throughout the house.

I am working with a microbiologist on several cases where the occupants of existing homes and new homes have been hospitalized for serious seizures, blackouts or swelling of the extremities.

Some of the problems originated with mold from the base cove flashing after the interior-drain tiles were replaced and others from charred wood left after fire-damage repairs. One house had a furnace installation where the filter could not be removed, and after two years, the mold and yeast buildup on the filter caused severe toxic reactions to the homeowner.

In conclusion, the cove joint flashing should not be open to the basement. The concrete should seal to the wall over the top of the flashing, or the flashing should be flush with the top of the floor and the joint sealed with a polyurethane caulk.

—Donald V. Cohen, P. E., building consultant, Thiensville, WI

Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

Affordable IR Camera

This camera is super useful for tracking down air leaks in buildings. The one-hand pistol grip arrangement frees your other hand for steadying yourself while maneuvering tricky job sites.
Buy at Amazon

Reliable Crimp Connectors

These reliable, high-quality connectors from Wirefy work on 10-22-gauge wire have heat-shrink insulation to keep out water and road salt.
Buy at Amazon

8067 All-Weather Flashing Tape

Available in 2- to 12-in. widths, this is a good general-purpose flashing tape that sticks well to most things. It features a two-piece release paper, water-shedding layers, and good UV resistance.
Buy at Amazon

Sign up for eletters today and get the latest how-to from Fine Homebuilding, plus special offers.

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters
×

Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters

New Feature

Fine Homebuilding Forums

Ask questions, offer advice, and share your work

  • X
  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • pinterest
  • email
  • add to favorites Log in or Sign up to save your favorite articles

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Sign up Log in

Become a member and get full access to FineHomebuilding.com

Up Next

Video Shorts

Featured Story

A New Approach for Millwork Finishes

The LED-cure products from LED Coating Solutions offer a fast-curing, zero-VOC finish that works well for trim and cabinetry in small shop settings.

Featured Video

Builder’s Advocate: An Interview With Viewrail

Learn more about affordable, modern floating stairs, from design to manufacturing to installation.

Related Stories

  • Podcast Episode 684: Masonry Heaters, Whole-House Ventilation, and Porch Flooring
  • Podcast Episode 683: Barndominiums, ERVs, and Radon Mitigation
  • Podcast Episode 682: Basement Flooring, Architectural Salvage, and HVAC Ducts
  • Fine Homebuilding Issue #331 Online Highlights

Discussion Forum

Recent Posts and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
View More Create Post

Highlights

Fine Homebuilding All Access
Fine Homebuilding Podcast
Tool Tech
Plus, get an extra 20% off with code GIFT20

"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.

Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters

Video

View All Videos
  • Podcast Episode 678: Live from the Builders' Show-Part 2
  • Podcast Episode 677: Live from the Builders' Show-Part 1
  • FHB Podcast Segment: The Best of the Fine Homebuilding Podcast, Volume 8
  • FHB Podcast Segment: Larsen-Truss Retrofit to Existing Stud-Frame House
View All

Fine Homebuilding Magazine

  • Issue 331 - June 2025
    • A More Resilient Roof
    • Tool Test: You Need a Drywall Sander
    • Ducted vs. Ductless Heat Pumps
  • Issue 330 - April/May 2025
    • Deck Details for Durability
    • FAQs on HPWHs
    • 10 Tips for a Long-Lasting Paint Job
  • Issue 329 - Feb/Mar 2025
    • Smart Foundation for a Small Addition
    • A Kominka Comes West
    • Making Small Kitchens Work
  • Issue 328 - Dec/Jan 2024
    • How a Pro Replaces Columns
    • Passive House 3.0
    • Tool Test: Compact Line Lasers
  • Issue 327 - November 2024
    • Repairing Damaged Walls and Ceilings
    • Plumbing Protection
    • Talking Shop

Fine Home Building

Newsletter Sign-up

  • Fine Homebuilding

    Home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox.

  • Green Building Advisor

    Building science and energy efficiency advice, plus special offers, in your inbox.

  • Old House Journal

    Repair, renovation, and restoration tips, plus special offers, in your inbox.

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters

Follow

  • Fine Homebuilding

    Dig into cutting-edge approaches and decades of proven solutions with total access to our experts and tradespeople.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
    • LinkedIn
  • GBA Prime

    Get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
  • Old House Journal

    Learn how to restore, repair, update, and decorate your home.

    Subscribe Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
  • Fine Homebuilding

    Dig into cutting-edge approaches and decades of proven solutions with total access to our experts and tradespeople.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
    • LinkedIn
  • GBA Prime

    Get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
  • Old House Journal

    Learn how to restore, repair, update, and decorate your home.

    Subscribe Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X

Membership & Magazine

  • Online Archive
  • Start Free Trial
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Magazine Renewal
  • Gift a Subscription
  • Customer Support
  • Privacy Preferences
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Terms of Use
  • Site Map
  • Do not sell or share my information
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • California Privacy Rights

© 2025 Active Interest Media. All rights reserved.

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

  • Home Group
  • Antique Trader
  • Arts & Crafts Homes
  • Bank Note Reporter
  • Cabin Life
  • Cuisine at Home
  • Fine Gardening
  • Fine Woodworking
  • Green Building Advisor
  • Garden Gate
  • Horticulture
  • Keep Craft Alive
  • Log Home Living
  • Military Trader/Vehicles
  • Numismatic News
  • Numismaster
  • Old Cars Weekly
  • Old House Journal
  • Period Homes
  • Popular Woodworking
  • Script
  • ShopNotes
  • Sports Collectors Digest
  • Threads
  • Timber Home Living
  • Traditional Building
  • Woodsmith
  • World Coin News
  • Writer's Digest
Active Interest Media logo
X
X
This is a dialog window which overlays the main content of the page. The modal window is a 'site map' of the most critical areas of the site. Pressing the Escape (ESC) button will close the modal and bring you back to where you were on the page.

Main Menu

  • How-To
  • Design
  • Tools & Materials
  • Video
  • Blogs
  • Forum
  • Project Guides
  • Reader Projects
  • Magazine
  • Members
  • FHB House

Podcasts

  • FHB Podcast
  • ProTalk

Webinars

  • Upcoming and On-Demand

Podcasts

  • FHB Podcast
  • ProTalk

Webinars

  • Upcoming and On-Demand

Popular Topics

  • Kitchens
  • Business
  • Bedrooms
  • Roofs
  • Architecture and Design
  • Green Building
  • Decks
  • Framing
  • Safety
  • Remodeling
  • Bathrooms
  • Windows
  • Tilework
  • Ceilings
  • HVAC

Magazine

  • Current Issue
  • Past Issues
  • Magazine Index
  • Subscribe
  • Online Archive
  • Author Guidelines

All Access

  • Member Home
  • Start Free Trial
  • Gift Membership

Online Learning

  • Courses
  • Project Guides
  • Reader Projects
  • Podcast

More

  • FHB Ambassadors
  • FHB House
  • Customer Support

Account

  • Log In
  • Join

Newsletter

Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters

Follow

  • X
  • YouTube
  • instagram
  • facebook
  • pinterest
  • Tiktok

Join All Access

Become a member and get instant access to thousands of videos, how-tos, tool reviews, and design features.

Start Your Free Trial

Subscribe

FHB Magazine

Start your subscription today and save up to 81%

Subscribe

This is your last free article.

Don't miss another expert tip or technique from building pros. Start your free trial today.

Start your FREE trial

Already a member? Log in

We hope you’ve enjoyed your free articles. To keep reading, become a member today.

Get complete site access to expert advice, how-to videos, Code Check, and more, plus the print magazine.

Start your FREE trial

Already a member? Log in

Privacy Policy Update

We use cookies, pixels, script and other tracking technologies to analyze and improve our service, to improve and personalize content, and for advertising to you. We also share information about your use of our site with third-party social media, advertising and analytics partners. You can view our Privacy Policy here and our Terms of Use here.

Cookies

Analytics

These cookies help us track site metrics to improve our sites and provide a better user experience.

Advertising/Social Media

These cookies are used to serve advertisements aligned with your interests.

Essential

These cookies are required to provide basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website.

Delete My Data

Delete all cookies and associated data