What's the Difference: Finish-nail guns
Time will tell if the new oil-free nailer can compete with long trusted oil nailer.
It never bothered me much to oil a nail gun every morning. The process became habitual, like putting on my tool belt or sharpening my pencil. So I was confused when manufacturers began pushing oil-free technology in their finish nailers some years ago. I saw the value in eliminating potential oil spray on quality, stain-grade trim, but being a skeptic, I wondered what this small bit of convenience—not having to oil a gun daily—really cost. In truth, it doesn’t cost much.
In defense of oil
To get a fresh perspective on the benefits of oil, I got in touch with Bosch, which recently released a line of pneumatic nail guns, none of which are oil-free. Bosch’s testing showed that the silicone O-rings, which are typically used in oil-free guns because of their inherent lubricity, don’t stand up as well or as long as traditional O-rings lubricated with petroleum oil. Also, Bosch says that if oil is accidentally added to an oil-free gun, the petroleum can damage silicone O-rings and require that they be replaced.
The lesson: If the convenience of an oil-free nailer appeals to you, investigate the O-ring material. Silicone may not be the best and may lead to shorter tool life or higher maintenance costs.
Praise for oil-free
Several companies, including Porter-Cable, Senco, Bostitch, and Milwaukee, offer oil-free finish nailers. Some take a roundabout approach when explaining how the parts in their guns are lubricated. For example, Senco simply says it gives its guns a one-time lubrication during assembly, while Porter-Cable says it relies on “Maintenance-Free Long Life Technology,” which allegedly increases the wear life of the O-rings and resists the damaging effects of petroleum oil if it’s added to a gun. While this all sounds like marketing hype, manufacturers stand behind their testing, which shows that the performance of oil-free guns is on par with traditional oiled models.
The lesson: Oil-free technology may bump up gun prices slightly, but it has resulted in a tool that’s easier and cleaner to use—with comparable longevity.
Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products
Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.
8067 All-Weather Flashing Tape
Handy Heat Gun
Reliable Crimp Connectors
