A carpenter is hoping to start his own remodeling business, but he doesn’t know if this is the right time or how to get started.

Auto1dact is nearing 30. His current job is a mix of supervisory and worker-bee responsibilities that earn him about $35,000 a year, and he doesn’t see much room for growth. He’s happy to have a job in an economy that has put plenty of people out of work, but in the long run, he’s convinced he can do better.

What skills can he take with him? From the sound of it, good basic carpentry, and some drywall and electrical experience, but he recognizes that he has some distance to go.

“Through my job, I’ve got a great education in residential construction, but I doubt my own abilities as a craftsman,” he writes in a post in the Breaktime business forum. “I’m handy in every aspect of home construction, but don’t have smooth, professional-level skills in anything.

“I feel really lost,” he adds, “like I’ve got all this unused potential but don’t know where to put my effort.”

Find a better job first

Before striking out on your own, davidmeiland suggests, get a better job with an established company.

“You may need more time as a lead carpenter in order to develop yourself as a job-site manager,” he says, “and you definitely need more time in the office.”

On a recommended to-do list: Learn more about sales, estimating, contracting, and subcontracting, among other things.

“You don’t mention how many total years you have in, but my belief is you need at least five and possibly many more to develop as a real journeyman carpenter,” davidmeiland says. “Probably more like 10, strictly in the field. At that point you’ll know a bunch about the other trades you need to manage. Then you need another three to five in the office in a seriously responsible role.”

Although $35,000 may not look great, it’s better than Auto1dact will probably do in the first years on his own. One mistake as a rookie contractor could cost that much alone.

JeffyT agrees: Find a job with another company. Part of his reasoning may be Auto1dact’s own description of his skills, or a general unease about not knowing quite enough to make it on his own. His ability to learn things quickly, though, will be an asset.

“You sound tentative about your own skill set but quick to pick up new stuff,” JeffyT says. “Get set up with someplace where you’ll have some leadership expectations on you, maybe some estimating and project management after you’ve been there a while. Someplace with a good reputation for quality and character.”

Learning from an employer’s mistakes

Auto1dact had hoped to pick up some of these things at his current job, but that didn’t pan out. Case in point: His boss recently needed mediation to settle a change-order bill that ran into six figures. “The client kept asking for significant rework, and we kept doing it, apparently without billing him or offering estimates for the work,” he says. “But then he got a bill and we got fired, and the project closed down and negotiations started.

“If my next move does prove to be a different employer, I’d like to work for a smoothly run company.”

But that’s a way to learn too, adds JeffyT. He also started his own business. Before he jumped ship, though, he kept a list of mistakes he saw at his company that he never wanted to make himself. The discipline made him look and listen carefully to the business practices he saw around him, some of them intentional.

Exactly right, posts hipaul. He worked for someone for a few years who was an excellent builder but a poor communicator who couldn’t estimate project costs accurately. “I watched for a few years,” he says, “and when I finally decided it was time to up and start out on my own, I took those lessons with me the most.”

Hipaul had no business plan, no idea of what the future held for him, not even that much knowledge about carpentry and construction. What he did have was a conviction that honesty with clients at all times was crucial, as was a willingness to “say ‘yes’ to just about anything.”

It takes a lot of skills to make it

JoeH, in business for 30 years, said it took a third of that time to learn that bean counting is just as important as the work that gets done.

“You need to be aware that knowing how to build a house and running a business aren’t the same thing,” he says. “The paperwork of a business is the most critical part of the deal, doesn’t matter whether or not you can change a blade. Do you have any idea how many pieces of paper it takes to build a $1,000,000 house?

“A smoothly run company really doesn’t have much to do with how to change a blade. It’s all about how much the blade cost, and making sure it’s accounted for at the end.”

Bobbys’s experience was much the same. He spent years remodeling, framing, and trimming for others, then ran a crew of his own, and finally went out on his own in his 30s.

“I needed every bit of skills I learned to make it,” Bobbys adds. “Everything I learned saved me from disaster.”

He did, however, lack business and selling skills, something that’s hard to pick up in books. Not only are solid carpentry skills a must, but so are selling, business, money management, and bookkeeping skills. “I always thought my trade skills would be enough,” he adds. “It was not.”

It also takes a leap of faith

While there was a strong undercurrent of caution in the posted responses, there also was a sense that determination and grit might overcome a lot of obstacles.

Kivi, for example, tells the story of the biggest builder in his city who started in his 20s with no building experience and only borrowed money. He started with a single spec house and now builds between 50 and 100 homes a year, along with strip malls, small office buildings, and retirement homes, “all of which they own and lease out.” The family is by now very wealthy.

“It all began with a commitment to the task at hand,” Kivi writes, “and it did not require even as much knowledge as you already have. You don’t need to be a craftsman on every (or any) aspect of the actual building job. There is no single right way to achieve what you want, but it won’t happen without a commitment to the dream.

“When you act like the kind of person that makes their dreams happen and can make the decisions required, you will also end up being treated like that kind of person. ”

Our expert’s opinion

We asked GBA advisor Jim Sargent, a custom builder and remodeling contractor in the Dallas area, for this thoughts. Here’s what he had to say:

“Every successful builder I know is a true entrepreneur, a person who manages risk and assumes responsibility. Most of them manage people and not tools. They manage customers, sales, craftsmen, bankers, everyone involved in each project. I have been a builder for over 35 years. My title has not changed, but my job description seems to constantly evolve. It is a very exciting and rewarding business to make things happen.”

Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

Reliable Crimp Connectors

These reliable, high-quality connectors from Wirefy work on 10-22-gauge wire have heat-shrink insulation to keep out water and road salt.

Buy at Amazon

Affordable IR Camera

This camera is super useful for tracking down air leaks in buildings. The one-hand pistol grip arrangement frees your other hand for steadying yourself while maneuvering tricky job sites.

Buy at Amazon

8067 All-Weather Flashing Tape

Available in 2- to 12-in. widths, this is a good general-purpose flashing tape that sticks well to most things. It features a two-piece release paper, water-shedding layers, and good UV resistance.

Buy at Amazon