Creating Two Beautiful Bathrooms Out of One

Synopsis: This article details the creation of two baths from one. By taking a little space from the bedroom and closet, and by eliminating a traditional bathtub in the suite bathroom, the builder left room for a walk-in shower and a new soaking tub in the secondary bath. Existing utilities were relocated and built-in closets make up for lost storage. With the entries to the bathrooms converging in a tight space, the solution was to modify and join two individual pocket-door frames to create a bypass pocket door, which is featured in the article in a detailed illustration and before-and-after floor plans.

When my wife, Doris, and I decided to upgrade the suite bedroom of our 28-year-old home, we turned to our most trusted source of building information for help—family. Dale Berns of Metro Homes, a builder and remodeler in the Minneapolis area for over 30 years, is Doris’s brother. We had dreamed about a suite addition for years and had developed several plans, which included everything from absorbing an adjoining bedroom to accommodate a large suite bath to creating a completely new space built over the garage. In the end, Dale came up with a plan that didn’t require an addition or losing a bedroom but gave us exactly what we were looking for: a dedicated bath for the existing suite bedroom.

Two baths from one

A full bath was serving the entire house, and itself was in need of a remodel. Dale developed a plan that took a small amount of space from three areas—the existing bath, the suite bedroom, and its adjoining walk-in closet—to create a new suite bath. 

Dale didn’t require the space of a typical suite bath to provide a luxurious, spa-like experience. His innovative plan showed that utilizing a single vanity and eliminating the traditional bathtub in the suite bath would require less real estate. This provided room for a generously sized walk-in shower. A new soaking tub with a tiled surround would replace the old alcove tub in the main bath. A slightly smaller footprint also meant that we would spend less overall on materials, allowing us to choose higher-quality finishes for both baths. A new walk-in closet would be positioned directly off the suite bath, separated by a pocket door with a mirrored panel. To accommodate the new bath and closet configuration, the bedroom area was reduced by less than 10 sq. ft. As part of the plan, the existing main bath would get a complete remodel at the same time. 

Squeezing in a suite bath Taking just a little space from the bedroom, closet, and existing bathroom allowed the builder to create a new bath for the suite without losing the hall bath that serves the other bedrooms on the floor. Existing utilities were relocated, allowing him to rearrange the walls. In both baths, built-in closets that push into the space over the garage make up for lost storage, as does a wardrobe in the suite bedroom. A generous shower area in the suite bath evokes the feeling of a larger bath.

Construction solutions 

The project started with the usual messy demolition. Dale removed most of the walls and ceilings from both the existing bath and the closet. He uncovered and repaired some minor water damage and roughed-in new plumbing and electrical. Somewhat outside the scope of the bath remodel, we decided to take the opportunity while the house was under construction to replace our outdated heating and air-conditioning systems and to add a new water heater. And, of course, we added ducting for new exhaust fans in each bath.

The original bath had pocket doors, and given the tight space, we wanted the same in the new design. But the main and new suite-bath entries were side by side, which posed a problem. The frames would overlap and would have to be sandwiched to make room for both the doors, resulting in a thick wall. Dale came up with an idea that saved space. He modified and combined two pocket-door frames so that the doors pass by each other inside the wall as they open. With no windows available, opaque glass in the suite-bath pocket door allows natural light to filter in from the bedroom windows.

Dale specializes in finish carpentry, so we had him build custom vanities and linen cabinets for both baths. He was able to add even more storage by recessing cabinets into the back walls of both rooms, utilizing unused attic space above the garage. 

A style of their own

Each bath had its own design considerations. The intent was to design the main bath in a traditional style, while letting the suite bath lean toward a more modern aesthetic. Dale used quartersawn oak, soapstone, and a matte-­finish white subway tile with tumbled marble trim and flooring for the main bath. He refit antique oak doors for the cabinets, evoking a Craftsman look. 

In contrast, the suite bath was wrapped in Carrara marble and trimmed in clear fir to match the suite-bedroom trim. A tall side panel built into the suite’s towel cabinet frames a piece of leaded glass, allowing in light while creating privacy. Access to the new walk-in closet also has a space-saving pocket door, made functional with a beveled-mirror panel for dressing. 

Tying it all together

Both baths have recessed LED lighting in the ceilings and toe-kick lights under the vanities. In the main bath, Dale installed recessed LED strip lighting around the medicine cabinet as well. 

The suite-bath closet was smaller than the original, so Dale also installed a built-in wardrobe cabinet in the bedroom for additional storage. It was also updated with a new bay window, new flooring, new recessed lighting, and sconces, and Dale removed the popcorn ceiling. He also updated the hallway outside the suite bedroom with oak flooring, new doors, and new trim.

“It’s a game of inches,” says Dale. “The most important thing is to look at the way the space will be used and then make the most from what you have to work with.” We couldn’t agree more. 

A traditional hall bath Quartersawn oak cabinetry, a soapstone counter, green marble floor tile, and a subway-tile wainscot and shower surround evoke a Craftsman design in the hall bath. A band of mosaic tumbled-marble tile adds a splash of color to the white subway tile. The recessed linen cabinet has salvaged antique oak and obscured glass doors.

More details

Countertops: Suite bath, Nu Shapes Carrara marble; Main bath, Nu Shapes soapstone

Cabinets and millwork: Suite bath, Douglas fir; Main bath, quartersawn white oak (custom by Dale Berns)

Wall tile: Suite bath, Tile Shop polished Meram Carrara; Main bath, Tile Shop, Imperial Brite White subway

Flooring: Suite bath, Hampton Carrara Tumbled Hex; Main bath, Biltmore Tumbled

Mirrors: Suite bath, Kohler Verdera; Main bath, custom by Dale Berns

Sink and faucets: Delta

Tub: Kohler Bancraft alcove bath

Toilets: Kohler Santa Rosa

Michael R. Anderson is an art director, writer, photographer, and technical illustrator. Photos by the author. 

Drawing: John Hartman

Originally published as “Game of Inches: A builder’s clever solutions for storage and style shine as he fits a master bath into a tight floor plan” in the 2018 Fall/Winter issue of Kitchens & Baths.

Fine Homebuilding #279

Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

Not So Big House

This book earned author Sarah Susanka a reputation as a small house guru, yet, that wasn’t exactly her goal. This book isn’t about building a small house, it’s about building a smart house, one that matches how we live, and prioritizing beauty and comfort over size.

Buy at Amazon

Graphic Guide to Frame Construction

Now in it’s 5th edition, Rob Thallon’s book for builders has been a go-to resource for decades. This book features clear graphics that will help you understand how nearly all American houses are — or should be — built.

Buy at Amazon

Musings of an Energy Nerd: Toward an Energy-Efficient Home

Fine Homebuilding readers know Martin Holladay well and love his practical, cost-effective approach to energy-efficiency and green building. In this book, he walks you through every step of planning an energy-smart home that is healthy, durable, and comfortable.

Buy at Amazon