Our archive is evergreen—by which I mean that rooms depicted in OHJ don’t date themselves quite like those in most shelter magazines. Others chronicle trends (if you’ve picked up a 1950s magazine in a secondhand shop and giggled at the décor, you know what I mean).

Most of the houses in OHJ feel timeless: because they are old to begin with and because their interiors are designed to complement the house. Less is torn out to be replaced by the new. Tradition and character play a bigger role. Also significant is that many of the houses we feature belong to OHJ readers, self-educated and creative, who act as their own decorators. Their houses are unique and far more personal than those professionally choreographed.

Holistic Design With a mix of antique and new, restored architecture and renovated spaces, most of what we feature are not purist “period rooms.” How to account for the sense of inevitable composure in them? Again, it’s because owners and designers respond to the age, style, and unique aspects of the house. Design is a process of elimination. What’s left is appropriate. Even when contemporary finishes and furnishings are introduced in an old house, rhyme and reason dictate scale, shapes, and colors.

The houses we’ve showcased date from three centuries plus; some have been period pieces, others interpretive, still others a study in bringing minimalism to an interior filled with antiquity. Some have been over-the-top mansions but others were restored on tight budgets.

A common theme has been preservation of original elements, even if they are worn. Another is the creation of a “scenario”—an imagined timeline or back-story that suggests a continuum between what was part of the original building and the often-necessary changes that came later.

Lessons Learned – The Bath If any cohort still appreciates the easy-to-clean privacy of a three-fixture bathroom designed to accommodate a single occupant, it’s old-house people. A good light fixture or bit of wallpaper can elevate the simplest cottage bath—or a pink-and-grey room ca. 1952. That said, we’ve published newly designed bathrooms that reflect Victorian built-ins, the “sanitary” white craze of the early 20th century, and jazzy Art Deco style. The best of the past is revived: think console sinks and tile, not carpeted steps leading to a sunken tub.

One could “date” an addition not to last year but to a much earlier change of ownership. The imagined scenario might inform today’s design of, say, a new bathroom in an outhouse-era Colonial, or a Depression kitchen in a Victorian row house. If there is a single thread that connects all, however, it’s this: The owners bought an old house on purpose. They wanted the ghosts.

Style Inspirations OHJ’s sister publication Old-House Interiors ran a column called “Inspired By,” which showed a renovated space accompanied by the historic house, room, or object that had inspired the new work. A staircase based on one in England, a kitchen island cued by a vintage worktable, a painted ceiling dreamt up after a trip to Morocco—we didn’t run out of material. Inspiration comes not only from the house itself but perhaps from an unrestored gem in the neighborhood, from a visit to a museum house of similar age and style, from out-of-print books, from the carvings on an antique. Very often, new design reflects an undertanding of period conventions or of the vernacular. Learning that shellacked beadboard was typical in seacoast cottages ca. 1880s–1910 might jump-start the direction of a restoration.

Design “Rules”

So, OHJ’s coverage has been on one hand historical, on the other quirky; we have published both unretouched survivors and replica houses. This club is diverse and unafraid. Still, people ask if any “rules” of renovation and interior design might save us from obvious traps and expensive mistakes.

Rules? Maybe not. As in most creative endeavors, the best work is by people who learned the rules and thus when to break them. Some guidelines, however, may help.

1.) Knowledge is Power

Understanding the period and style of a house mercifully narrows choices, allowing a head start. More importantly, that knowledge teaches us to differentiate between what is original and what was remodeled, and how the windows should look. You get what you pay for. This is almost always true. Do without, wait and save up, rather than subbing in short-lived materials or settling for poor craftsmanship.

2.) Respect the Architecture

Future owners will curse big changes that obscure the original design and period integrity in favor of individual taste and passing trends. You saw that when you were house-hunting. Paint plaster walls chartreuse or fuchsia… but don’t be the first one to paint 140-year-old figured mahogany intrinsic to the 1880s opulence of the dining room.

3.) Scale is Everything — Regardless of Style or Personal Taste

Better to use a contemporary adaptation in an appropriate scale (for the mantel, in a wallpaper pattern or the size of the breakfront) rather than a period element that isn’t a fit.

4.) Don’t Be Afraid of Color

Our ancestors clearly were not. All-white rooms are a recent affliction. Be personal. It isn’t just a house, it’s your home. Ignore the TV pundits du jour. That said, express your quirkier taste in a way that doesn’t permanently damage the house.

RELATED STORIES

• Collected Old Wood in a New Kitchen
• A Home for All Seasons
• Connected in Antiquity

Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

Code Check 10th Edition: An Illustrated Guide to Building a Safe House

It would be great if this book didn’t need to exist, but it's definitely a must-have. It's a one-size-fits-all code book that's easy to understand and will help you sail through your inspections.

Buy at Amazon

The New Carbon Architecture: Building to Cool the Climate

With this book, architect Bruce King changes the conversation around what it means to build a green home. Take everything you thought you knew about the topic, and just set it aside and let Bruce explain why embodied carbon trumps the rest of what is undoubtedly important.

Buy at Amazon

Musings of an Energy Nerd: Toward an Energy-Efficient Home

Fine Homebuilding readers know Martin Holladay well and love his practical, cost-effective approach to energy-efficiency and green building. In this book, he walks you through every step of planning an energy-smart home that is healthy, durable, and comfortable.

Buy at Amazon