FHB Logo Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter X Instagram Tiktok YouTube Plus Icon Close Icon Navigation Search Icon Navigation Search Icon Arrow Down Icon Video Guide Icon Article Guide Icon Modal Close Icon Guide Search Icon Skip to content
Subscribe
Log In
  • How-To
  • Design
  • Tools & Materials
  • Restoration
  • Videos
  • Blogs
  • Forum
  • Magazine
  • Members
  • FHB House
  • Podcast
Log In

Discussion Forum

Discussion Forum

Alternatives to Cedar Shakes

[email protected] | Posted in General Discussion on April 23, 2009 06:19am

I’m looking for alternatives to cedar shakes, for reroofing, older existing structures. 

I’m the Facilities Engineer for the Salmon-Challis National Forest.  Which means that I have the responsibility of trying to maintain 400+ old buildings, 90% of which are eligible for listing on the National Historic Register, and roughly 50 are listed.  So, they all have to maintain their historic style, and finish schedule.  Which is white with  medium dark green trim and roofs.

90% of them have cedar shake roofs, which since we are in the high desert, have severe issues with deterioration from being snow covered all winter, and then dried in the summer, (the relative humidity at most sites is less than 10%). 

I met with the State Historic Preservation Office yesterday, and they have indicated that they would be amenable to allowing alternate materials for the roof, provided the aesthetic of the cedar shakes can be maintained. 

The other issue, is whatever roofing system I use has to be green to be historically accurate.  So, I need to be able to purchase it prefinished in the green, or it needs to paintable/stainable. 

So, any information on options would be greatly appreciated. 

Reply
  • X
  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • pinterest
  • email
  • add to favorites Log in or Sign up to save your favorite articles

Replies

  1. seeyou | Apr 23, 2009 06:28pm | #1

    http://www.follansbeeroofing.com/products/KlassicKolors_colors.aspx

    http://www.certainteed.com/products/roofing/residential/designer/308747#  look at hunter green

    http://www.certainteed.com/products/roofing/residential/premium-designer/309005 look at augusta green

     

    http://www.quittintime.com/      View Image        

    1. Henley | Apr 24, 2009 02:19am | #2

      I guess you have that covered.

    2. User avater
      Jeff_Clarke | Apr 24, 2009 08:30am | #3

      Actually this one - http://www.certainteed.com/products/roofing/residential/premium-designer/317950 does a fair job of imitating wood shingles/shakes.

      Unfortunately it's become very difficult to get good quality cedar shingles.

      Jef

      1. marv | Apr 24, 2009 03:40pm | #4

        Hard to find and very expensive.

        View Image

        You get out of life what you put into it......minus taxes.

        Marv

        Edited 4/24/2009 8:41 am by Marv

        1. User avater
          Matt | Apr 25, 2009 11:56pm | #13

          You really need to stop using your level as a pry bar....

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

           

          :-)

  2. Marson | Apr 24, 2009 03:58pm | #5

    This probably won't help but...I worked at a retreat center in the North Cascades that was on the Registry of Historic Places. Had the same issue. There are many imitation shakes out there, and the facilities manager (my boss) looked at most. Finally managed to lobby the powers that be to allow standing seam steel. The argument that worked was fire safety (this is in a remote area where forest fires are a very real threat).

    I wasn't impressed with any of the fake shake samples that were a constant fixture in the office.

    1. mike_maines | Apr 24, 2009 04:55pm | #6

      I don't know, it's hard to beat the look of real cedar:

      View Image

      We looked into Southern Pine for this job http://www.lifepine.com/ but it just doesn't have quite the same look.

      Considering the location though, I would think some sort of metal roof would be appropriate and longer-lasting?

      1. theslateman | Apr 25, 2009 11:57am | #7

        Mike,

        That red metal bracket is doing a number on that beautiful cedar.

        Walter

        1. mike_maines | Apr 25, 2009 08:48pm | #9

          Yeah, the carpenters decided that they should match the existing white cedar 5" exposure instead of the 6" exposure I estimated, so we had to wait a couple weeks for the rest of the material in the wettest part of last winter.  It should clear right up though, southern exposure and all.

  3. User avater
    shelternerd | Apr 25, 2009 03:46pm | #8

    Nichiha makes a fiber cement shingle look-alike that is pretty durn convincing. I'd use it for a roof over a good substrate but I'm not sure it's listed as a roofing material with the manufacturer.

    ------------------

    "You cannot work hard enough to make up for a sloppy estimate."

  4. frenchy | Apr 25, 2009 09:31pm | #10

    Am I correct in understanding you need to paint the roofs? 

      If so what I did was dip the shake in  an oil baesed paint and let it dry   once dry  I put a second coat of latex on and That's resulted in an extremly durable finish..

    1. [email protected] | Apr 25, 2009 09:48pm | #11

      They have to end up green. You are right that the right way to paint them would be to dip them, but unfortunately, the person I'm replacing didn't know that, and now I have some roofs less than five years old, that are already splitting and cracking. I'm trying to get a replacement for the shakes, because in this climate, the combination of being buried in the snow all winter, and then dried to a moisture content that is less than half of kiln dried means the shakes only have a ten year life, before the roof starts to leak. Of course someone has decided that they should last twenty years, so I can't get budget to fix them when needed. Add to that, the fact that the shake roofs are extremely fire prone, and I really want them gone.The whole historical part drives me nuts, because I am fairly certain the original roofs were done using Douglas Fir shakes, a native tree in this forest.

      1. mike_maines | Apr 25, 2009 10:34pm | #12

        A sales rep brought these into our office recently: http://www.microposite.com/.  He said they are the best thing since sliced bread for walls, and that although he wasn't supposed to recommend them for roofs he knew people who had used them on roofs with good results.

      2. frenchy | Apr 26, 2009 01:09am | #15

        OK you have issues that won't be easily  resolved..

          First document the roof leaks  take pictures and describe in as complete a gory detail the leaks and damage resulting..

         That should get you the authorization to repair them..  next  describe the issue of fire safety  and the flamibility of cedar shingles.. make the statement that originally the roof wouldn't have been painted green since green paint was an extremely expensive color originally..

         Suggest standing metal roof that's green or  steel shingles painted green.. as a last resort  your dipped green shingles should look extremely modestly priced..

      3. User avater
        Jeff_Clarke | Apr 26, 2009 02:49am | #17

        Believe it or not, historically they used to use a lot of spruce here in the east for shingles - back when labor was cheap ...

        Jeff

        Edited 4/25/2009 7:50 pm ET by Jeff_Clarke

        1. seeyou | Apr 26, 2009 03:05am | #18

          historically they used to use a lot of spruce here in the east for shingles

          I suspect old growth spruce was about equal to farmed cedar.http://www.quittintime.com/      View Image        

  5. User avater
    Matt | Apr 26, 2009 12:00am | #14

    Sorry - I'm no help.

    Why though, from a historic standpoint, are the roofs green?  Are the authentic ones just cedar with heavy moss/algae/whatever on them?   I think I've seen that in the Pac NW, but it is hard for me to imagine in a dry environment like you describe.... 

    1. [email protected] | Apr 26, 2009 02:30am | #16

      It was something that was done in the 1930's by the CCC's. They painted all the buildings white, and the roof, doors and trim green. On some structures they added 3-inch wide, 2-inch exposure cedar siding, over the top of what had been white washed board and batten.

  6. Tyr | Apr 26, 2009 05:02am | #19

    In the Denver Metro Area (semi-arid)shakes were popular and I still like them. However, insurance companies consider them to be a fire hazard and charge a 20% surcharge. Due to the hail the area experiences a plain old 3 tab shingle falls in the "no extra charge" category for insurance. There are dimensional shingles of heavier (thicker) construction considered 30 year roofs (some 40)that qualify for a 10% discount. So stripping the shakes and installing a better asphalt shingle roof (that looks like shakes)could result in a 30% savings.

    Maybe everything there is self insured--but for others it counts. Tyr

    Things are not always what they seem; the first appearance deceives many; the intelligence of a few perceives what has been carefully hidden.... Roman Poet Phaedrus 15BC–50AD
    1. User avater
      Dinosaur | Apr 26, 2009 05:37am | #20

      installing a better asphalt shingle roof (that looks like shakes)

      Sorry, but that's an oxymoron. No asphalt shingle looks like shakes.

      The essence of the look in a shake roof is a combination of the thickness of the shakes themselves, the random widths, and the irregularity of the hand-split surface. No machine-made, production-line product can imitate that with any degree of success. Some so-called 'architectural' asphalt shingles attempt to do so but wind up looking (IMO) like a cross between a patchwork quilt and a 1970s version of computer 'wallpaper'.

      Comparing asphalt shingles to shakes is like comparing screw-down steel to standing seam copper. Maybe worse.

      Dinosaur

      How now, Mighty Sauron, that thou art not broughtlow by this? For thine evil pales before that whichfoolish men call Justice....

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Sign up Log in

Become a member and get full access to FineHomebuilding.com

Video Shorts

Categories

  • Business
  • Code Questions
  • Construction Techniques
  • Energy, Heating & Insulation
  • General Discussion
  • Help/Work Wanted
  • Photo Gallery
  • Reader Classified
  • Tools for Home Building

Discussion Forum

Recent Posts and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
View More Create Post

Up Next

Video Shorts

Featured Story

Podcast Episode 686: Brick Steps, Ground-Source Heat Pumps, and Greenhouses in Nova Scotia

Listeners write in about fireplaces affecting family harmony and bionic suits, before asking questions about brick steps, ground-source heat pumps, and building a dome greenhouse in Maritime Canada.

Featured Video

Video: Build a Fireplace, Brick by Brick

Watch mason Mike Mehaffey construct a traditional-style fireplace that burns well and meets current building codes.

Related Stories

  • Podcast Episode 686: Brick Steps, Ground-Source Heat Pumps, and Greenhouses in Nova Scotia
  • FHB Podcast Segment: Efficient HVAC for a New Build
  • Affordable Scans, Accurate Plans
  • FHB Summit 2025 — Design, Build, Business

Highlights

Fine Homebuilding All Access
Fine Homebuilding Podcast
Tool Tech
Plus, get an extra 20% off with code GIFT20

"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.

Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters

Fine Homebuilding Magazine

  • Issue 331 - June 2025
    • A More Resilient Roof
    • Tool Test: You Need a Drywall Sander
    • Ducted vs. Ductless Heat Pumps
  • Issue 330 - April/May 2025
    • Deck Details for Durability
    • FAQs on HPWHs
    • 10 Tips for a Long-Lasting Paint Job
  • Issue 329 - Feb/Mar 2025
    • Smart Foundation for a Small Addition
    • A Kominka Comes West
    • Making Small Kitchens Work
  • Issue 328 - Dec/Jan 2024
    • How a Pro Replaces Columns
    • Passive House 3.0
    • Tool Test: Compact Line Lasers
  • Issue 327 - November 2024
    • Repairing Damaged Walls and Ceilings
    • Plumbing Protection
    • Talking Shop

Fine Home Building

Newsletter Sign-up

  • Fine Homebuilding

    Home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox.

  • Green Building Advisor

    Building science and energy efficiency advice, plus special offers, in your inbox.

  • Old House Journal

    Repair, renovation, and restoration tips, plus special offers, in your inbox.

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters

Follow

  • Fine Homebuilding

    Dig into cutting-edge approaches and decades of proven solutions with total access to our experts and tradespeople.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
    • LinkedIn
  • GBA Prime

    Get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
  • Old House Journal

    Learn how to restore, repair, update, and decorate your home.

    Subscribe Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
  • Fine Homebuilding

    Dig into cutting-edge approaches and decades of proven solutions with total access to our experts and tradespeople.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
    • LinkedIn
  • GBA Prime

    Get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
  • Old House Journal

    Learn how to restore, repair, update, and decorate your home.

    Subscribe Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X

Membership & Magazine

  • Online Archive
  • Start Free Trial
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Magazine Renewal
  • Gift a Subscription
  • Customer Support
  • Privacy Preferences
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Terms of Use
  • Site Map
  • Do not sell or share my information
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • California Privacy Rights

© 2025 Active Interest Media. All rights reserved.

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

  • Home Group
  • Antique Trader
  • Arts & Crafts Homes
  • Bank Note Reporter
  • Cabin Life
  • Cuisine at Home
  • Fine Gardening
  • Fine Woodworking
  • Green Building Advisor
  • Garden Gate
  • Horticulture
  • Keep Craft Alive
  • Log Home Living
  • Military Trader/Vehicles
  • Numismatic News
  • Numismaster
  • Old Cars Weekly
  • Old House Journal
  • Period Homes
  • Popular Woodworking
  • Script
  • ShopNotes
  • Sports Collectors Digest
  • Threads
  • Timber Home Living
  • Traditional Building
  • Woodsmith
  • World Coin News
  • Writer's Digest
Active Interest Media logo
X
X
This is a dialog window which overlays the main content of the page. The modal window is a 'site map' of the most critical areas of the site. Pressing the Escape (ESC) button will close the modal and bring you back to where you were on the page.

Main Menu

  • How-To
  • Design
  • Tools & Materials
  • Video
  • Blogs
  • Forum
  • Project Guides
  • Reader Projects
  • Magazine
  • Members
  • FHB House

Podcasts

  • FHB Podcast
  • ProTalk

Webinars

  • Upcoming and On-Demand

Podcasts

  • FHB Podcast
  • ProTalk

Webinars

  • Upcoming and On-Demand

Popular Topics

  • Kitchens
  • Business
  • Bedrooms
  • Roofs
  • Architecture and Design
  • Green Building
  • Decks
  • Framing
  • Safety
  • Remodeling
  • Bathrooms
  • Windows
  • Tilework
  • Ceilings
  • HVAC

Magazine

  • Current Issue
  • Past Issues
  • Magazine Index
  • Subscribe
  • Online Archive
  • Author Guidelines

All Access

  • Member Home
  • Start Free Trial
  • Gift Membership

Online Learning

  • Courses
  • Project Guides
  • Reader Projects
  • Podcast

More

  • FHB Ambassadors
  • FHB House
  • Customer Support

Account

  • Log In
  • Join

Newsletter

Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters

Follow

  • X
  • YouTube
  • instagram
  • facebook
  • pinterest
  • Tiktok

Join All Access

Become a member and get instant access to thousands of videos, how-tos, tool reviews, and design features.

Start Your Free Trial

Subscribe

FHB Magazine

Start your subscription today and save up to 70%

Subscribe

Enjoy unlimited access to Fine Homebuilding. Join Now

Already a member? Log in

We hope you’ve enjoyed your free articles. To keep reading, become a member today.

Get complete site access to expert advice, how-to videos, Code Check, and more, plus the print magazine.

Start your FREE trial

Already a member? Log in

Privacy Policy Update

We use cookies, pixels, script and other tracking technologies to analyze and improve our service, to improve and personalize content, and for advertising to you. We also share information about your use of our site with third-party social media, advertising and analytics partners. You can view our Privacy Policy here and our Terms of Use here.

Cookies

Analytics

These cookies help us track site metrics to improve our sites and provide a better user experience.

Advertising/Social Media

These cookies are used to serve advertisements aligned with your interests.

Essential

These cookies are required to provide basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website.

Delete My Data

Delete all cookies and associated data