FHB Logo Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter X Instagram Tiktok YouTube Plus Icon Close Icon Navigation Search Icon Navigation Search Icon Arrow Down Icon Video Guide Icon Article Guide Icon Modal Close Icon Guide Search Icon Skip to content
Subscribe
Log In
  • How-To
  • Design
  • Tools & Materials
  • Restoration
  • Videos
  • Blogs
  • Forum
  • Magazine
  • Members
  • FHB House
  • Podcast
Log In

Discussion Forum

Discussion Forum

Cedar clapboard vs. Hardie Plank

ChicagoMike | Posted in General Discussion on March 19, 2007 01:19am

I am about to undertake the siding on my own home. I have done alot of repairs to siding but never an entire home. Obviously I could never use vinyl. I think if I even thought of it, I would be banned from the Breaktime forums. I would like to know how cadar and hardie plank compare in price, ease of install, longevity, opinions on beauty. My home is what has been referred to as a “carpenter’s victorian” by my neighbors. It is victorian with out all of the gingerbread. And while we are at it what do you suggest for trim? Azak, cedar, composite? Any imput would be greatly appreciated.

Reply
  • X
  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • pinterest
  • email
  • add to favorites Log in or Sign up to save your favorite articles

Replies

  1. User avater
    user-246028 | Mar 19, 2007 02:58am | #1

    What I recommend to people around here is the Hardiboard Siding with Prefinished Cedar Trim. HardiTrim is disgusting in appearance. Their siding is beautiful, but the trim is horrible. The prefinished trim is far more attractive.

    As far as what will last longer, Hardi all the way. Cementboard siding will last longer than you and me put together.

    Dave

  2. bruce22 | Mar 19, 2007 03:13am | #2

    There's a big price difference between cedar and Hardi plank, even fj primed cedar. If you're particular about keeping the original look of smooth finish, the Hardi won't cut it. The wood grain isn't exactly a historic look. The smooth finish Hardi looks like painted masonite or worse. My local yard in W.Mass. recently started carrying a primed wood clapboard that I hadn't heard of before.   At .57 LF,  a  little more than the Hardi but a lot cheaper than cedar.

    1. ChicagoMike | Mar 19, 2007 06:08am | #6

      I am not too far from MA. What is this product and at what lumber yard?

      1. bruce22 | Mar 21, 2007 03:21pm | #38

        Sorry for the delayed response. At Dresser-Hull in Lee, MA they started carrying Paulownia fj primed clapboard and 1x trim to replace their previous line. The clapboard is 1.39 bf, I was off on my previous post.

        1. ChicagoMike | Mar 22, 2007 07:04am | #45

          Thank you Bruce, I am familiar with Dresser Hull. I will check it out.

  3. User avater
    DDay | Mar 19, 2007 04:53am | #3

    Hardie is great and the Azek trim paints great and will last forever. I've used both with great results. Do a search of old threads for all kinds of info.

    Blind nail the hardie, I think the siding nailers work best. And get a pair of shears for dustless cutting. I have the snapper shears from Pacific tool, model 404. They are about $200 but worth every penny to cut without the dust. If this is a one time job then you can resell them on ebay after (or buy them off ebay if your timing is right). On ebay I think they sell for around $150. I think snapper are the best but porter cable makes a pair too.

    http://www.pactool.us/snappershear/

  4. User avater
    McDesign | Mar 19, 2007 05:39am | #4

    Much as I like some things about Hardi, it's just too dang thin - shadow lines aren't substantial enough.

    My only real complaint.

    Forrest

    1. ChicagoMike | Mar 19, 2007 06:06am | #5

      EXACTLY what I thought. I ahve been racking my brain to decide which is more important, shadowline or inexpensive longevity.

      1. User avater
        McDesign | Mar 19, 2007 06:22am | #7

        Plus, try doing this with Hardi -

        http://forums.taunton.com/tp-breaktime/messages?msg=73188.197

        Forrest

        1. User avater
          mjishere | Mar 19, 2007 08:51am | #8

          Hardie is just plain ghetto....and mark my words, there will be a class action lawsuit in the future....hopefully there is someone or something left for the class to go after.Does anyone on the west coast remember, in the mid to late 80's, a lightweight tile roofing product that was supposed to last a lifetime? In fact I even think it was called "LifeTile" or something close to that. Poof!...those forever roofs magically turned into lightweight tile roofing dust, after they were exposed to the rain and leached out a solution that was very alkaline....which promptly attacked the cellulose binder matrix.....and Presto!!! Only by the time the lawsuits got underway, the company, now facing a bazillion lawsuits (because their product was so widely used, thanks to a builder kickback scheme that perfectly mirrors "Hardie-Bucks", not to mention the lucrative incentives that the supply houses received for pushing it) the company had no choice but to file for protection from their creditors....yup...bankruptcy. My parents had one of those roofs, they never received a dime.Just so everyone doesn't think that I am pulling this out of my a**, I have a Bachelors degree in chemistry, working towards a Masters, and have closely examined and experimented with the Hardie Plank product.Cedar and Redwood were engineered by Mother Nature, I trust her a heck of alot more than some bozo at the Hardie lab....case in point, several of my classmates pursued chemical engineering degrees, doing so on scolarship courtesy of the HUGE endowment of the School of Pulp and Paper Sciences at the Univ of Washington (yup, of which James Hardie is a contributor) and I wouldn't trust them to mix a Mentos and a 2 liter of Diet Coke.Just a thought....MJ

          1. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 19, 2007 12:53pm | #9

            Tell me more about this 'close examination and testing' you've done with Hardi-Plank please.  Because unless you provide a few tangible FACTS, you are indeed pulling this out of your azz.  Degree or no degree. 

             View Image

          2. DanH | Mar 19, 2007 01:41pm | #10

            I think what will happen is that the pressure to get cheaper and cheaper will take its toll. The stuff you put up now will last longer than the stuff you put up ten years from now.
            So convenient a thing it is to be a reasonable Creature, since it enables one to find or make a Reason for everything one has a mind to do. --Benjamin Franklin

          3. User avater
            mjishere | Mar 19, 2007 01:50pm | #11

            Hardie is composed of a cementitious mixture that is bound by a cellulose fibre matrix. Basically kinda like adobe brick is made, but instead of clay/mud and straw, it uses a cementitious composition and strands of paper/wood. The resulting mixture is then extruded with that lovely cedar grain pattern....and voila' you have a Hardie Plank. (Not rocket science....or even chemistry really). The exposure of the product to rainwater (such as when used as siding) which is acting as a Lewis acid, causes a reaction with the alkaline cementitious base, producing a salt and leaving behind a solution of very high Ph (ie: caustic) which then attack the latticework of paper/wood....and over time I bet you can guess what happens. Yup...just like a certain roofing product. Try this if you are still skeptical. Go buy yourself a nice shiny, new, unprimed chunk of Hardie....on your way home stop at Safeway and pick up a container of Red Devil drain cleaner. This is almost 100% Sodium Hydroxide. Next make a solution by charging a vessel (a glass Pyrex measuring cup ONLY!) with 1500ml of distilled water and adding a tablespoon at a time of Sodium Hydroxide crystals, swirling between each addition, until no more crystals will dissolve and go into solution. PLEASE wear safety goggles and PVC GLOVES while doing this, as this stuff will blind you if splashed in your eyes, and burn the snot out of your skin if it contacts it. Also be advised that the solution will get VERY HOT as the breaking of bonds that occurs as it goes into solution is HIGHLY EXOTHERMIC, so BE CAREFUL. After the solution has had a chance to cool then transfer it to a plant sprayer (preferably with Viton seals) and then place the Hardie where you can access all sides of it. Finally apply the solution, making sure that you coat it on all sides thoroughly. Repeat this process each time the HP dries...until you run out of solution. Watch what happens....curious isn't it? Hmmmmmmmm......azz eh?See..... chemistry really is fun !!MJ

          4. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 19, 2007 06:04pm | #12

            That's awesome.  I'll be sure and remember to not strip all the primer and paint off my house and spray it down with drain cleaner.  Thanks for the heads up.View Image

          5. doodabug | Mar 21, 2007 11:59pm | #41

            I think dumb upsets you more than it use to?

          6. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 22, 2007 12:05am | #42

            LOL.... maybe dude.  I dunno.  Why, you think I'm gettin' cranky?View Image

          7. doodabug | Mar 22, 2007 12:09am | #43

            Little bit maybe

          8. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 22, 2007 12:20am | #44

            I'll take a look at it.   My sense of humor is really sarcastic though.  Sometimes sarcasm doesn't translate so well over the internet.  I can see where it could come across as angry or frustrated or something.  I appreciate your honesty.  (That wasn't sarcastic)View Image

          9. freestate1 | Mar 19, 2007 08:42pm | #14

            You've got to be kidding...  Hardi is bogus because it won't stand up to repeated applications of drain cleaner?  LOL.

            Reminds me of a guy who told me in a serious tone that the "Club" steering wheel locks were no good because all a would-be thief had to do was spray it with liquid nitrogen and it would shatter with the slightest blow.  

          10. User avater
            mjishere | Mar 22, 2007 03:30pm | #48

            In FACT it would do precisely that...at least where I am from, criminals often show a remarkable level of resourcefulness. Liquid nitrogen is relatively simple to procure. To the same extent, it could also freeze and shatter other things ....like ones fingers. I guess it is really all in your perspective....mine is "The Club" is easily defeated...and...Hardie Plank, especially if not completely sealed with finish (INCLUDING end cuts...) will eventually fail miserably. On the bright side....all of you guys whom were making your money doing LP lap siding replacement, (which by the way failed as a result of improper coating/sealing of the manipulated edges, and at the selvage, where water "wicked" into the matrix of the product) can transition seamlessly to Hardie-Plank siding replacement, hopefully you didn't nail the sh*t out of it.Just a thought,MJ"Most Changes Aren't Permanent, But Change Is..."

          11. woodturner9 | Mar 23, 2007 06:26pm | #65

            Hardie Plank, especially if not completely sealed with finish (INCLUDING end cuts...) will eventually fail miserably.

            You are certainly entitled to your opinions, but folks here might be more accepting of your views if you posted some facts or evidence to support the conclusion.  Especially since Hardi plank has been around for decades, and shows none of the effects you seem concerned about.

            Nothing is forever, though - I suspect my ancestors will eventually have to replace the Hardi Plank I have installed.  But I bet it's longer than the 15-20 year life of vinyl or wood.

             

          12. User avater
            aimless | Mar 19, 2007 10:31pm | #15

            You've totally lost me. You talk about the ill effects of acid rain on hardi siding, but then you tell us how to test it with drain cleaner, which is the opposite of acid. 

            Where did you get your degree in chemistry again?

          13. User avater
            mjishere | Mar 22, 2007 03:46pm | #49

            Maybe you should try and re-read my post...although I am certain that I write in a somewhat technical style, I nonetheless think that you may understand the "gist" of the post, should you choose to review it and not just (after a cursory read) spout off some "let me on the bandwagon " kind of statement, like "blah...blah...blah... so where did you get your chemistry degree again?". (by the way, to answer your inquiry fully....Bachelors=University of SF, Graduate=University of Puget Sound)I only point this out because I THOUGHT this was someplace that people came to share ideas and learn from others.....not just stroke each others ego's. Respectfully,MJ"Most Changes Aren't Permanent, But Change Is..."

          14. User avater
            aimless | Mar 22, 2007 06:08pm | #54

            I did read your post, and I hadn't read the other "bandwagon" posts before I replied.  Apparently you didn't read my entire post, because you did not address anything but the last question. Your "technical style" notwithstanding: you attacked hardi on the basis of it's resistance to acid and then your supporting evidence was using a very caustic base.  That's a simple mistake and I would have overlooked it except you threw your degree in there as if that meant we shouldn't try and read what you said, just take it at face value.  That was on top of attacking your fellow students as being bad chemists.  Sorry if your feelings were hurt by my question, but based on your mistake it seemed unlikely that you were really a chemist. Congratulations on your degree.

          15. woodturner9 | Mar 23, 2007 06:28pm | #66

            That's a simple mistake and I would have overlooked it except you threw your degree in there as if that meant we shouldn't try and read what you said, just take it at face value.  That was on top of attacking your fellow students as being bad chemists.

            Did  you notice where he said his "degrees" were FROM?

          16. User avater
            aimless | Mar 23, 2007 08:05pm | #67

            "Did  you notice where he said his "degrees" were FROM?"

            I did, but I know nothing of those schools. I grew up in Delaware, with one of the better undergraduate ChemE degrees in the nation (at the time, I have no clue now).

          17. fingersandtoes | Mar 23, 2007 10:19pm | #68

            Lets be blunt. You are not getting flack because people like Hardiplank. You are getting it because of your rather unscientific experiment that you cloaked in technical jargon, and justified by referring to your credentials, rather than addressing its shortfalls.

            I find posting in Breaktime is often a humbling experience. Giving advice on topics that I think I am fairly knowledgeable about, I have found that a fair number of the people here have far greater experience. That's what makes it a valuable resource.

            Everyone makes mistakes. Move on and keep posting. I'm sure there are a number of topics where your experience  will prove useful.

             

          18. r | Mar 23, 2007 10:27pm | #69

            Just curious:  I looked at the website for the U of Puget Sound.  They advertise themselves as a liberal arts college, and the only graduate degrees they currently offer are in Education, Occupational Therapy, and Physical Therapy. 

            And we are all still curious about your answer to the acid / base question.  Your educational background notwithstanding, explaining that discrepancy is a necessary first step at establishing credibility here.

          19. woody1777 | Mar 27, 2007 03:03pm | #90

             

            ......only graduate degrees they currently offer are in Education, Occupational Therapy, and Physical Therapy. 

            And we are all still curious about your answer to the acid / base question.  Your educational background notwithstanding, explaining that discrepancy is a necessary first step at establishing credibility here.

             

            It's been four days now and we still don't have an explanation....hmmmm

            Maybe there is no explanation. Except " Hey, You're right, I pulled all that out of my azz"

             

             

             

            That's awesome.  I'll be sure and remember to not strip all the primer and paint off my house and spray it down with drain cleaner.  Thanks for the heads up.   dieselpig '07

             

          20. r | Mar 27, 2007 04:23pm | #91

            Yep, there is an unpleasant odor in the air.

          21. fingersandtoes | Mar 28, 2007 06:13am | #92

            Maybe he is too busy studying...

          22. User avater
            DDay | Mar 28, 2007 10:44pm | #93

            maybe he was a victim of a drain cleaner experiment?

          23. User avater
            Matt | Mar 20, 2007 01:34am | #17

            I totally agree!  All the cement board siding that has been installed unprimed and unpainted will be worthless in 40 or 50 years and will have to be stripped off and replaced.  Great job security for my great grand kids who will undoubtedly be carpenters because they want to follow in pappie's footsteps :-)

          24. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 20, 2007 01:45am | #18

            LOL...View Image

          25. mikeroop | Mar 29, 2007 04:41am | #97

            if you read the label it says not to get it wet until after it's painted.

             

             

            why do we always think we know more than mother nature or can do things better?

          26. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 29, 2007 04:52am | #98

             

            if you read the label it says not to get it wet until after it's painted.

             

            And your point is........???????View Image

          27. mikeroop | May 10, 2007 01:20pm | #99

            wood doesn,t fall apart if it gets wet before paint, fiber cement board does! i've seen it happen with hardi and others many times.

          28. MikeHennessy | May 10, 2007 05:34pm | #100

            "wood doesn,t fall apart if it gets wet before paint, fiber cement board does!"

            Hmmm. I left a bunch of Hardi siding and wood cutoffs outside, some on the ground, over the winter, pending the arival of the final dumpster for my addition job. The Hardi was as good as the day it was delivered. Same for a couple of leftover hunks of Hardi underlayment. No damage from being outside & wet over winter. No so much with the wood, which suffered the expected degradation from being outside & wet for 5 months.

            I have a neighbor who has an addition with Hardi siding and wood trim. One guess which is rotting and falling apart after two years. (Hint: It's NOT the Hardi.)

            Mike HennessyPittsburgh, PA 

          29. bd | May 10, 2007 11:38pm | #101

            I'm building a small outbuilding, about 1000 sq ft, now. Decided to use Hardi based on recommendations. To find out how it weathered, I took a piece of scrap, stuck it in a bucket of water (half in, half out) & left it outside last summer. It's still there. While the end in the water obviously soaked up some water, there was no softening & very little wicking into the part out of the water. Not until the freeze/thaw cycles hit during the winter was there any degradation to the piece at all. After the water froze solid & thawed several times you could see some delamination in the piece. I don't think it's likely to degrade in normal use.

          30. MikeSmith | May 10, 2007 11:47pm | #102

            i've used Ashland -Davis, Certainteed , & Hardi  fibercement starting in 1998.

            i've tested all three.. never saw anything at all resembling what you describe

            also.. i've been installing cedar claps since 1973...... have them on every house we've ever lived in   ( 4 so far)

            but i'll be using FiberCement on anything we build for our own accout .. and it's what i recommend to my customersMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore

          31. User avater
            dieselpig | May 11, 2007 01:02am | #103

            wood doesn,t fall apart if it gets wet before paint, fiber cement board does! i've seen it happen with hardi and others many times.

            Many times?  Many times?  Now I know you're FOS.  Gotta be 1000 builders who frequent this board, yet you're the only one who's seen this happen.  Not just once mind you..... but many times.

            Maybe you should tell the installers in your area to let their customers know it needs to be painted or something.  I'm still finding random scraps of the stuff in my yard from when I sided my house two summers ago.  In fact I was cutting in a new planting bed in my side yard last weekend and dug up a few scraps.  None of them were falling apart bro.  The ones that were buried were showing some signs of delamination but even I was surprised by how well they had held up.  The scraps in my yard that I come across seem to fairing equally well.  At first I thought some of them were actually remnants from the asbestos siding we pulled off because they had held up so well.

            So as long as don't strip the paint off my house and then get drunk and decide to either douse it in draincleaner or bury it.... I'm thinking I'll be all right for awhile.  But again.... thanks for the heads up.

             View Image

          32. Tim | Mar 22, 2007 08:19pm | #55

            This statement alone "...is then extruded with that lovely cedar grain pattern...." excludes you from those with a clue.

          33. ChicagoMike | Mar 22, 2007 11:52pm | #57

            WOW! Who knew this thread subject would get so heated. I LOVE it. I have always thought the more heated a discussion was, the more people cared about what they are saying. I want to thank ALL that replied to this, I really appreciate it. If anyone is going to JLC Live, I would love to meet you. I'll be the big fat guy with a black Marvin jacket on.

          34. User avater
            McDesign | Mar 23, 2007 02:29am | #58

            <the big fat guy>

            Hey!  You can't say that!  It's derogatory!

            Forrest - lookin' out for you

          35. woodpecker47 | Mar 23, 2007 03:03am | #59

            i did my whole house with factoryprimed cedarsiding(clapboard) on the lower half of the house and the top half with factory primed (oil) cedar shakes. then 2 coats of latex paint (california paints, consumer report rated it the absolut best for exterior). the cedarshakes have to be reprimed by me because the "tannin" in the shakes is bleeding through, maybe it's the oilprimer. if everthing is done right this paintjob will last  at least 12 years.  i went with wood all around and i have no regrets. the old wood i ripped off was 100 years old and 90% was in good shape, just to much paint on it. i vote is for wood. remember what they said about vinyl siding, maintenancefree and it last forever, yeah right.... good luck. maybe i post a picture of my house that will help you make up your mind , i just don't know how to do it.

          36. User avater
            Matt | Mar 23, 2007 03:41am | #60

            So, do the woodpeckers like your siding too? :-)

          37. User avater
            mjishere | Mar 23, 2007 11:22am | #61

            AAAHHHHHH Yes...the forever vinyl siding....ooops...wait ....does not UV light attack and degrade polymers over time?...?...? Welp, so much for not having to maintain it. This gentlemen is why we still have GLASS, not POLYMER windshields. Woodpecker47, regarding wood finishes, both film and penetrating, check out the Forest Products Laboratory website - http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/. It is a veritable cornucopia of information, regarding all things WOOD, (sorry, no FC fans allowed). As far as voting goes...of course, my ballot is marked WOOD also. Regards,MJ"Most Changes Aren't Permanent, But Change Is..."

          38. ChicagoMike | Mar 24, 2007 07:50am | #71

            Does anyone have a ballpark cost per square for cedar?

          39. ChicagoMike | Mar 24, 2007 08:04am | #73

            Why not? I am the giant fat guy. I can say that about my self all I want. I LOVE to eat!

          40. MikeSmith | Mar 24, 2007 02:03pm | #74

            mike... sorry i missed you at jlc.. if you get a chance ... go back  and go to the Malco booth this morning

            they have the best fibercement tools

            especially the shears  and the red plastic guages... really.. those two items will really make it easy working with Hardie

            if you miss it .. you can buy those tools at M&J Supply on Union Ave in Prov.Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore

          41. ChicagoMike | Mar 24, 2007 08:47pm | #82

            Thank you Mike, I will get the tools.

          42. User avater
            mjishere | Mar 23, 2007 11:31am | #62

            =======================================================
            This statement alone "...is then extruded with that lovely cedar grain pattern...." excludes you from those with a clue.
            =======================================================I love what you have done with the rhyme scheme, (extrude, exclude, and clue...Brilliant!!) insanely progressive, complex and edgy.....sort of Robert Frost pokes Andy Warhol-ish and yet for all it's sublime qualities, still maintains it's intensely powerful lyrical content. Attention everyone.... I'm gonna have to be the first to say it.....gentlemen, it appears as though we are fortunate enough to have ourselves a budding poetical genius among us.

            and.....HE was inspired by the likes of me...yeah..me...can you believe it....are you sure I am worthy of such a high pedestal?So please Tim, tell us....just a hint....c'mon.....so when does the coffee table version of your literary work hit the shelves at Amazon?....Because I for one am gonna be first in line to pre-order it. In awe, I remain...your biggest fan,MJ
            Tim Fanclub Member #00001

            Edited 3/23/2007 4:57 am by mjishere

          43. mojo | Mar 23, 2007 01:44pm | #63

            In all serious, he has a point about your knowledge of how FC is created.  What did you mean by extrude?  How is a textured surface extruded? 

          44. Mark_T | Mar 23, 2007 02:57pm | #64

            Pretty smart guy - aren't you?

            Science touches every aspect of life.  It's has roots in probably all industries.  The problem is that actual experience, field testing, etc, trumps it every time.

            I once had a neighbor who was a college professor.  He was planting a small bush in his yard in hard dirt.  Picture this: Overweight guy with pasty skin and soft hands is sweating profusely as he digs a quart sized hole with a 3' "lady shovel".  He is all red in the face.  I glanced over there occasionally as I was cutting my grass.  After about an hour I went over there to talk...  He was just about to get the shrub in the hole.  I told him: "I have this theory that the ability to perform labor is inversely proportional to intelligence."  It was a compliment, of sorts.  Translation:  Smart guys sometimes have trouble just getting stuff done.  Too much theory involved. 

            Of course, the world smart people can make their way in a large variety of situations, as opposed to the book smart people who excel in more controlled environments.

            Now Miss Jis: take your toys and degrees and run along and play somewhere else.  Maybe this web site: http://www.spartechsoftware.com/reeko/    Lots of high school chemistry stuff to mess with over there.

          45. MikeSmith | Mar 20, 2007 12:58am | #16

            yur so fulla shid , yur eyes are brown

            hardie has been installed  in Australia for more than 20 years

             AND

             the only difference between fiber cement and the old asbestos cement siding is the lack of asbestos and the extra thickness in the modern product

            i can go to any of 20 homes in my town, the old asbestos cement siding looks as good  ( or as bad ) as the day it was installed in 1930...

             your testing is suspect

            also... hardie is not the only mfr. of fiber cement siding..

             Ashland Davis was well established before Certainteed bought them

             

            Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore

            Edited 3/19/2007 6:04 pm ET by MikeSmith

          46. woody1777 | Mar 20, 2007 02:03pm | #25

            hardie has been installed  in Australia for more than 20 years

            I thought I heard that Hardie had been around in the states for 30-40 years, dont remember where I heard that though.....

            We put up a sh!tload of the 8 14' board the last 10 years or so, no acid rain drain cleaner callbacks yet.

            He's just another good example of somebody with their head up their theoretical azz....

          47. User avater
            mjishere | Mar 22, 2007 03:59pm | #50

            Mike....I am sure that you have read the "Breaktime" Forum rules on postings that are of a personally derogatory nature (semantics included) otherwise...you are gonna get this happygram in your inbox...=======================================================MikeSmith,
            Please familiarize yourself with our forum guidelines. We don't allow
            vulgar language or personal insults on our forum. This will be your one
            and only warning before being removed from the forum for
            a period of two weeks. Thanks for your cooperation. -FHB Moderators.=============================================================Breaktime is brought to you by The Taunton Press. Visit us on the
            Web at http://www.taunton.com.=======================================================...I'm just trying to look out for you bro'.....I got your back brother...takin' care of ya, you know brah'. :-)...Late...MJizzle"Most Changes Aren't Permanent, But Change Is..."

          48. MikeSmith | Mar 22, 2007 04:01pm | #51

            thanks, jizz... your concern  underwhelms meMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore

          49. User avater
            mjishere | Mar 22, 2007 04:09pm | #53

            Just lookin' after you...I know you'd do the same...right?...Thanks Bro!Your Friend,mJIZZle or Jizz for you my brother"Most Changes Aren't Permanent, But Change Is..."

          50. milt96 | Jan 19, 2023 05:18pm | #104

            HI mjishere, I know it's been a few years since your post but it is now 2023 and I'm curious if this is still a concern that I should be looking into.

  5. mcf | Mar 19, 2007 08:14pm | #13

    I was just at my local yard picking up a quotation for Anderson windows and noticed a display board for a new siding product. I was leaning towards hardiplank myself and know i am very interested in learning about this product.

     

    http://www.nucedar.com/

     

    anyone know anything about this?

    1. ChicagoMike | Mar 20, 2007 04:56am | #19

      Thank you sir. After reading all of the responses, I am leaning away from Hardie.

      1. edwardh1 | Mar 20, 2007 05:08am | #20

        Hardie is great stuff.
        if you do not like it you can use wood and paint it , and paint it, and paint it then replace some and paint it and paint it and replace some more

        1. ChicagoMike | Mar 20, 2007 05:15am | #21

          I understand. I guess I am being gun shy because this is my own home. I wouldn't think twice about putting it on someone else's home. I am most concerned about the shadowline. Does anyone have an opinion about using a 1" rip of the material to beef up the bottom thickness of the plank to better match the 1/2" on cedar?

          1. RobWes | Mar 20, 2007 05:32am | #22

            Sorry but around here the Hardie thickness is very close to the wood product I've seen at the exposed edge. Hardie does not have the taper however.

            I have seen wood properly installed with paint on all sides and it still flys off. I'f I'm paying for clear wood siding, I don't want to look at paint anyway. Stain looks great for a start but don't last long.

            For a soild color I took my chances with Hardie.

          2. edwardh1 | Mar 20, 2007 02:30pm | #27

            nobody notices the shadow lines .I am in a condo projevt = we did 2 sides of a big 2 story building with hardie, the other two are older wood no one noticed.
            the hardie on my son in laws home is 10 years old- looks like installed last month.wood pops splits cracks oozes expands shrinks warps and generally sheds paint
            hardie does none of those

          3. MikeSmith | Mar 20, 2007 03:01pm | #28

            BTW... i still prefer the Certainteed to the Hardie.. but for some reason, Certainteed can't compete on price in our area...

            anyone else notice this ?Mike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore

          4. User avater
            Timuhler | Mar 20, 2007 04:30pm | #30

            Mike,

            I was going to price CertainTeed because I like the look better than Hardi.  When we were in Orlando for IBS (not the digestive disorder) :-) we looked at it and it does look better.  When I get pricing, I'll let you know.

             

            Tim

          5. ChicagoMike | Mar 22, 2007 11:47pm | #56

            Mike,

             

            Can you tell me why you prefer the Certainteed over the Hardie. I have never seen the Certainteed. Thanks.

          6. ANDYSZ2 | Mar 20, 2007 03:02pm | #29

            I think certainteeds  or other manufacturers make a slightly thicker board so look at different product lines if thickness is a concern.

            ANDYSZ2WHY DO I HAVE TO EXPLAIN TO FRIENDS AND FAMILY THAT BEING A SOLE PROPRIETOR IS A REAL JOB?

            REMODELER/PUNCHOUT SPECIALIST

             

          7. User avater
            Luka | Mar 20, 2007 10:39pm | #32

            "I understand. I guess I am being gun shy because this is my own home. I wouldn't think twice about putting it on someone else's home."WHAT ??!!?Are you sure you worded that correctly ?

            Hey, don't look at me, I'm mentally retireded.

          8. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 20, 2007 10:48pm | #33

            LOL... I was thinking the same thing.  My homes have always been my laboratories.  Whipped up a few Frankensteins too now that I think about it.  My first tile job, my first FC siding job, lotsa paint experiments, crown, first solo roof strip, first lawn tear-out/replace..... busted all those cherries on my own home.View Image

          9. ChicagoMike | Mar 21, 2007 01:12am | #34

            Now that you gave me the fresh perspective, that was a pretty asinine thing to say. Thanks for the heads up.

          10. User avater
            Luka | Mar 21, 2007 01:46am | #36

            As Alltrade has pointed out, it was just the presentation.Happens to all of us.=0)

            Hey, don't look at me, I'm mentally retireded.

          11. AllTrade | Mar 21, 2007 01:23am | #35

            I don't think thats a bad statment myself Mike. I am sure there are many here who installed vinyl siding and Hardie who would not use it on there own home. Just because its ok for others does not mean its ok for me. I have installed a lot of Hardie but would never use it on my home. I don't like the way it looks myself.

          12. User avater
            Luka | Mar 21, 2007 01:46am | #37

            In that context, yes.=0)Good point.

            Hey, don't look at me, I'm mentally retireded.

          13. jja28 | Mar 21, 2007 04:12pm | #39

            I agree completely regarding the installing on your own house versus a customer's house. We install Hardie all the time (so much I'm tired of it).Personally the only Hardie product I like is shingled panel. By those I don't mean the individual shingles (4, 8 and 12"), I mean the 48" panels that are cut out to look like individual shingles. They go on fairly easily (one guy can do it if he's on his own), fairly quickly, and have a good look, IMO. (Downside is I think they're quite a bit more expensive).My main dislike with Hardi lapped siding (we do 8 1/4" mostly, but other sizes have this same drawback), is how it conforms to the wall so much. What I mean by that is it shows every imperfection in the wall...studs out of alignment...a piece of plywood that may have a little buckle to it, etc. If your wall is bad, the Hardi will look bad afterwards. You can try and "float" or "fir" out your panels as you go along, stud by stud, but even doing that it can still look like crap. The shingled panels help hide most imperfections in bad framing, due to the large number of vertical lines. It doesn't fix the wall, but the many vertical lines help play tricks on your eyes (which is good in this case).If you've got straight walls, then regular panels are not so bad, it goes on quickly and looks ok. I think shorter walls look better than longer walls. They help break things up a bit more.Just my .02

          14. DanH | Mar 21, 2007 05:04pm | #40

            All this makes me glad we were able to do our house in Masonite Woodsman before it was taken off the market. Thicker than Hardie but not as heavy, came in 16' sections, relatively little dust when cutting, not as hard to nail, stiffer and less likely to "telegraph" imperfections in the framing.
            So convenient a thing it is to be a reasonable Creature, since it enables one to find or make a Reason for everything one has a mind to do. --Benjamin Franklin

          15. RobWes | Mar 22, 2007 03:19pm | #47

            The cost of the shingle panels was frightning. It really was what I wanted but then there are a lot of things in life I want but can not afford. I recall a number of 400/sq. maybe?

            Great point on having a good base to nail the Hardie to as it will show every wave in a wall. I was lucky in that my builder paid attention to details and supplied high quility work. Of course I paid for it too.

        2. User avater
          mjishere | Mar 22, 2007 04:03pm | #52

          Yeah...you must be short a few Hardie-Bucks...it's ok we understand...Hardie is great...just like that other siding product...by LP....and that EIFS Stucco system...another FABULOUS exterior finish.....I see...my mistake.MJ"Most Changes Aren't Permanent, But Change Is..."

      2. User avater
        DDay | Mar 20, 2007 05:40am | #23

        Do a search through the old threads, hardie is a very good product. The first one around here to use it was a local development company that produces some nice houses. The ones that are 10 plus years old look like they were just painted, they look great. If you question the shadow lines, then call hardie, certainteed or other fiber cement companies and see if they have some addresses of places you could see it in person. The wood and fiber cement around here looks the same as far as the shadow lines, the paint is the telling tale, the fc looks much better than the wood.Your local lumber yards might also know a few houses that have it on in the area. If you going to the JLC Live show in Providence this weekend, they have a good demo on hardie and a half dozen reps to talk to about it. They do an install on an 8 ft wall, so you can see what it looks like, cutting it, nailing it, etc.

        Edited 3/19/2007 10:42 pm ET by DDay

        1. ChicagoMike | Mar 20, 2007 12:49pm | #24

          I'll be at the JLC Live show Friday. Thank you for the info. I will look out for the Hardie Booth.

          1. User avater
            Matt | Mar 20, 2007 02:15pm | #26

            There is a historic area here in Raleigh NC.  To build a house there or do any kind of exterior work you have to get it approved by the historic preservation society for that neighborhood.  These people are tough to work with, have a manual of requirements to follow for exterior home and property appearance, and lawyers to enforce it.  Fiber cement siding (FC) is OK with them. 

            I'd say that although the shadow lines may not entirely historically accurate with FC, you would be lucky if one in a hundred people would notice it.  Remember though - it is you who will have to maintain the house.  Paint lasts longer on FC siding because FC doesn't expand and contract or absorb water the way wood does. 

            Regarding the above questioning of the longevity of fiber cement products - remember this is the internet.  Pick an opinion - any opinion - and you can find someone to support it.  For example, I'll bet I could do a Google right now and find someone who says Bush is pacifist. :-)

  6. mcf | Mar 20, 2007 04:32pm | #31

    You have mastered the art of winning friends and influencing people.

  7. Jer | Mar 22, 2007 02:14pm | #46

    Ultimately cedar looks better. FC will last however and the shadowline thing is for the picayune types like you and me. I would use Azak products for trim, they now make mouldings of all sorts. Did a house last year of FC and Azak, from the road it looks spectacular. Use the Certanteed brand.
    I do so much rot replacement that if it were my choice on my own house I would use FC and be done with it.

  8. User avater
    DDay | Mar 24, 2007 06:02am | #70

    You started the thread, did you check it out at JLC? If so, did you ask about the effects of "Red Devil drain cleaner" on fiber cement.

    1. ChicagoMike | Mar 24, 2007 08:02am | #72

      Yes I was at JLC, and I asked the rep about the drain cleaner. He got a good laugh out of it. We moved on and I actually liked the look of it. The only drawback to me is the unusual way to cut and install it with the dust and tools compared to cedar. As a so called purist, I would LOVE to install cedar but I can't afford it. I don't need a 3rd mortgage. I am already springing for Marvin windows. I think I'll have to go with Hardie based on price alone.

      1. DanH | Mar 24, 2007 02:23pm | #75

        One thing I don't like about the Hardie I've seen (at least I'm pretty sure it was Hardie) is the sharp, unrelieved edge. Looks pretty unnatural to me.
        So convenient a thing it is to be a reasonable Creature, since it enables one to find or make a Reason for everything one has a mind to do. --Benjamin Franklin

        1. edwardh1 | Mar 24, 2007 02:46pm | #76

          most wood has a sharp unrelieved edge.

          1. edwardh1 | Mar 24, 2007 02:48pm | #77

            I have conducted tests in my own home and if you let brake fluid sit on a formica surface it will stain the formica.
            Based on this I have decoided never to use Formica.
            Is this good thinking?

          2. User avater
            dieselpig | Mar 24, 2007 03:10pm | #78

            Yer on the right track.  On a similar note, I recently stopped stuffing my pants with fiberglass bats on cold days.View Image

          3. Southbay | Mar 25, 2007 09:18am | #84

            Yer on the right track. On a similar note, I recently stopped stuffing my pants with fiberglass bats on cold days.
            ------Why, fiberglass don't keep you warm enough?
            Try the Mooney pants, or maybe clothes cell foam is the answer.

          4. User avater
            McDesign | Mar 25, 2007 03:57pm | #85

            <Mooney pants>

            Love the mental picture!  Kind of horizontally quilted, like big corduroy.

            Forrest

          5. fingersandtoes | Mar 25, 2007 07:38am | #83

            Man, thanks for filling me in on the test. I have decided to stop using brake fluid.

          6. DanH | Mar 24, 2007 03:12pm | #79

            Yep, and then that edge is milled off.
            So convenient a thing it is to be a reasonable Creature, since it enables one to find or make a Reason for everything one has a mind to do. --Benjamin Franklin

          7. edwardh1 | Mar 24, 2007 03:26pm | #80

            Not on my all wood house 'cept where I have put on Hardie- dormers etc. wood seems to have a hard edge.

          8. edwardh1 | Mar 24, 2007 08:31pm | #81

            pix of wood and hardie- the wood is the one with missing paint and cracks warping etc.

          9. WNYguy | Mar 26, 2007 03:45pm | #88

            Dan, when I use cedar for repair work, I plane off the radius edge.  The 19th-century clapboards I'm matching always have a sharp edge.

            But the rounded edge holds paint better.  I think that's its main advantage.

            Andy Engle sided his house with Hardie, as I recall.  It looked good, and the crisp edges especially appealed to me.

            Allen

          10. DanH | Mar 26, 2007 04:44pm | #89

            Probably a regional thing. But especially softer woods like redwood seem to always have a radiused edge. And the Hardie edge is so sharp it looks like plastic sprue.
            So convenient a thing it is to be a reasonable Creature, since it enables one to find or make a Reason for everything one has a mind to do. --Benjamin Franklin

      2. User avater
        DDay | Mar 25, 2007 06:57pm | #86

        There are pro's and cons with both cedar and fiber cement. If you have to buy the shears (I have the snapper shears) or the malco attachment shears, you'll still be less money than the Stainless steel nails for cedar. With FC you'll just be blind nailing with roofing or siding nails and unless your near the ocean, galv's are fine.I just think when you add everything up, the higher price of cedar, the extra cost of SS nails, the lesser durability of paint/stain on cedar and its still wood so rot, carpenter bees, etc are an issue, FC is a better choice.I've heard the malco's for a drill work well but have never used them. Whether you get those or the snapper shears, if you don't need them again just post them here, ebay or local and sell them for 50% to 75% of what you paid and look at it as a rental cost.

        1. MikeSmith | Mar 26, 2007 03:49am | #87

          dday... we have two sets of the malco shears

          the malco guy says they will cut 1/2" hardie backer

           

          we also have the makita FC saw with the  shroud and vacuum attachment .. but we don't use it since we bought the malco'sMike Smith Rhode Island : Design / Build / Repair / Restore

  9. AllTrade | Mar 29, 2007 01:04am | #94

    I am number 100!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yeah!

    1. dovetail97128 | Mar 29, 2007 01:37am | #95

      Congratulations!!! You have just won a unit of Lousiana Pacific Inner Seal Wafer Board Siding!!! Just tell the truck driver where you want to start your new mushroom farm and he will drop it there!. ;-)

      1. AllTrade | Mar 29, 2007 03:54am | #96

        and my third grade teacher said I wouldnt amount to nothing. HA!

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Sign up Log in

Become a member and get full access to FineHomebuilding.com

Video Shorts

Categories

  • Business
  • Code Questions
  • Construction Techniques
  • Energy, Heating & Insulation
  • General Discussion
  • Help/Work Wanted
  • Photo Gallery
  • Reader Classified
  • Tools for Home Building

Discussion Forum

Recent Posts and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |
View More Create Post

Up Next

Video Shorts

Featured Story

FHB Podcast Segment: Are Single-Room ERVs the Answer?

Learn more about the pros and cons of single-room ERVs.

Featured Video

Builder’s Advocate: An Interview With Viewrail

Learn more about affordable, modern floating stairs, from design to manufacturing to installation.

Related Stories

  • Design and Build a Pergola
  • Podcast Episode 689: Basement Garages, Compact ERVs, and Safer Paint Stripper
  • FHB Podcast Segment: Are Single-Room ERVs the Answer?
  • Fire-Resistant Landscaping and Home Design Details

Highlights

Fine Homebuilding All Access
Fine Homebuilding Podcast
Tool Tech
Plus, get an extra 20% off with code GIFT20

"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.

Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters

Fine Homebuilding Magazine

  • Issue 332 - July 2025
    • Custom Built-ins With Job-Site Tools
    • Fight House Fires Through Design
    • Making the Move to Multifamily
  • Issue 331 - June 2025
    • A More Resilient Roof
    • Tool Test: You Need a Drywall Sander
    • Ducted vs. Ductless Heat Pumps
  • Issue 330 - April/May 2025
    • Deck Details for Durability
    • FAQs on HPWHs
    • 10 Tips for a Long-Lasting Paint Job
  • Issue 329 - Feb/Mar 2025
    • Smart Foundation for a Small Addition
    • A Kominka Comes West
    • Making Small Kitchens Work
  • Issue 328 - Dec/Jan 2024
    • How a Pro Replaces Columns
    • Passive House 3.0
    • Tool Test: Compact Line Lasers

Fine Home Building

Newsletter Sign-up

  • Fine Homebuilding

    Home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox.

  • Green Building Advisor

    Building science and energy efficiency advice, plus special offers, in your inbox.

  • Old House Journal

    Repair, renovation, and restoration tips, plus special offers, in your inbox.

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters

Follow

  • Fine Homebuilding

    Dig into cutting-edge approaches and decades of proven solutions with total access to our experts and tradespeople.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
    • LinkedIn
  • GBA Prime

    Get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
  • Old House Journal

    Learn how to restore, repair, update, and decorate your home.

    Subscribe Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
  • Fine Homebuilding

    Dig into cutting-edge approaches and decades of proven solutions with total access to our experts and tradespeople.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X
    • LinkedIn
  • GBA Prime

    Get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

    Start Free Trial Now
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
  • Old House Journal

    Learn how to restore, repair, update, and decorate your home.

    Subscribe Now
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • X

Membership & Magazine

  • Online Archive
  • Start Free Trial
  • Magazine Subscription
  • Magazine Renewal
  • Gift a Subscription
  • Customer Support
  • Privacy Preferences
  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Terms of Use
  • Site Map
  • Do not sell or share my information
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • California Privacy Rights

© 2025 Active Interest Media. All rights reserved.

Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.

  • Home Group
  • Antique Trader
  • Arts & Crafts Homes
  • Bank Note Reporter
  • Cabin Life
  • Cuisine at Home
  • Fine Gardening
  • Fine Woodworking
  • Green Building Advisor
  • Garden Gate
  • Horticulture
  • Keep Craft Alive
  • Log Home Living
  • Military Trader/Vehicles
  • Numismatic News
  • Numismaster
  • Old Cars Weekly
  • Old House Journal
  • Period Homes
  • Popular Woodworking
  • Script
  • ShopNotes
  • Sports Collectors Digest
  • Threads
  • Timber Home Living
  • Traditional Building
  • Woodsmith
  • World Coin News
  • Writer's Digest
Active Interest Media logo
X
X
This is a dialog window which overlays the main content of the page. The modal window is a 'site map' of the most critical areas of the site. Pressing the Escape (ESC) button will close the modal and bring you back to where you were on the page.

Main Menu

  • How-To
  • Design
  • Tools & Materials
  • Video
  • Blogs
  • Forum
  • Project Guides
  • Reader Projects
  • Magazine
  • Members
  • FHB House

Podcasts

  • FHB Podcast
  • ProTalk

Webinars

  • Upcoming and On-Demand

Podcasts

  • FHB Podcast
  • ProTalk

Webinars

  • Upcoming and On-Demand

Popular Topics

  • Kitchens
  • Business
  • Bedrooms
  • Roofs
  • Architecture and Design
  • Green Building
  • Decks
  • Framing
  • Safety
  • Remodeling
  • Bathrooms
  • Windows
  • Tilework
  • Ceilings
  • HVAC

Magazine

  • Current Issue
  • Past Issues
  • Magazine Index
  • Subscribe
  • Online Archive
  • Author Guidelines

All Access

  • Member Home
  • Start Free Trial
  • Gift Membership

Online Learning

  • Courses
  • Project Guides
  • Reader Projects
  • Podcast

More

  • FHB Ambassadors
  • FHB House
  • Customer Support

Account

  • Log In
  • Join

Newsletter

Get home building tips, offers, and expert advice in your inbox

Signing you up...

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
See all newsletters
See all newsletters

Follow

  • X
  • YouTube
  • instagram
  • facebook
  • pinterest
  • Tiktok

Join All Access

Become a member and get instant access to thousands of videos, how-tos, tool reviews, and design features.

Start Your Free Trial

Subscribe

FHB Magazine

Start your subscription today and save up to 70%

Subscribe

Enjoy unlimited access to Fine Homebuilding. Join Now

Already a member? Log in

We hope you’ve enjoyed your free articles. To keep reading, become a member today.

Get complete site access to expert advice, how-to videos, Code Check, and more, plus the print magazine.

Start your FREE trial

Already a member? Log in

Privacy Policy Update

We use cookies, pixels, script and other tracking technologies to analyze and improve our service, to improve and personalize content, and for advertising to you. We also share information about your use of our site with third-party social media, advertising and analytics partners. You can view our Privacy Policy here and our Terms of Use here.

Cookies

Analytics

These cookies help us track site metrics to improve our sites and provide a better user experience.

Advertising/Social Media

These cookies are used to serve advertisements aligned with your interests.

Essential

These cookies are required to provide basic functions like page navigation and access to secure areas of the website.

Delete My Data

Delete all cookies and associated data