Looking to switch from a manuel Porta-nailer to an air powered model. Anybody have a brand they prefer? I was looking at a PowerNail 445fs stapler and a Bostitch m111fs. Pros and cons of nail versus staples. Thanks.
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story

There is no generic 2-ft. rule. Use the code tables to dial in joist spans and overhangs based on accurate engineering.
Featured Video
How to Install Cable Rail Around Wood-Post CornersHighlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
I have the m111-fs. I haven't had a staple stuck in it yet. It has about 4500 square feet under it. Not a ton of flooring, but there still isn't a scratch on it. I love the pre-finished flooring foot. I can usually get about 30% more done it a day because of it since I don't have to keep picking it up and moving it. You just roll it along.
As a side benefit - the finish foot also keeps the stapler a lot more stable, no worries about it tipping and damaging the floor.JT
Definitely. And upgrading from a manual nailer, you'll wonder how you ever got by.
I purchased the air powered Porta Nails model "Porta A Matic Nailer 421" I laid 2,000 sq ft of red oak. A really great machine, no jambs. I used the 2 " "T" nails, about 15,000 nails.
Virginbuild
Hand nailing in my youth,I was able to lay 360' of 2" hardwood flooring,3¼ would have been much more,figure it out,it's easy enough.You young guys have got it too easy heh heh.
youre off topic lol
You can't go wong w/ either, but I hear the prefin./ foot setup is the sh*t. For hard (brittle ) species wood, you'll need nails. The staples are ALOT cheaper though. I have a Bostich air nailer & an Ebay brand stapler. They BOTH work great. You don't need a huge compressor. I have a Porter Cable "job boss". Big mistake unless you run 4 guns every day. Hope this helps.
Edited 8/28/2009 7:58 pm ET by NYFLOORGUY
I have 670 sq ft of soild 5/8 bamboo that looks similar to psl beams and was thinking that a nail would split the flooring. I am kind of stuck here, I have always had great luck with the Porta-nailer but I am done swinging that mallet 3 times as much as needed.
I had mine set on two hits,at the end of the day you knew you had been working.Still it was better than lookin at a busted thumb after hitting it with a 24oz hammer!
Regards,mack.
Saw a guy on TV a few years back, he designed and installed custom medallions in hardwood. 6' diameter geometric paterns, coat of arms, that kind of thing.
First he would lay the hardwood, pre-drilled and handnailed. Then they would sand the floor. The circle or whatever shape he needed to inlay the medallion was cut with a router.
IIRC, he was charging around $50k for a foyer.
The first guy I layed hardwood for had us do it the same way, pre-drill and handnail. I don't know if I'd like to try that again, I was a lot better with a hammer 30 yrs ago.
Pre drilled? Guess I never heard of that. I used to hand nail with the cut nails some years ago. The squared off ends used to push the wood through and not split it. I would set the nail with the head of the next nail. I know, that was old school, but I was taught that by a guy who was in his late 60's back in '78. You knew you had done a days work, especially your poor hands.
When I first tried a manual floor nailer, I thought I had died and gone to heaven.
I don't do that many floors anymore, but I have the Bostitch stapler. It's a wonder.
I pre-drill and hand nail a decent amount around the edges, but part of the benefit of using a flooring nailer is the mallet knocks the boards tight while driving the nail/staple. It's not as important with site finished flooring because it's grouted before finishing, but getting a whole load of pre-finished flooring that is straight as an arrow is almost impossible. there are always a few hockey sticks.