Looking to switch from a manuel Porta-nailer to an air powered model. Anybody have a brand they prefer? I was looking at a PowerNail 445fs stapler and a Bostitch m111fs. Pros and cons of nail versus staples. Thanks.
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
The RealTruck AMP Research Bedsteps give you easy access to your truck-bed storage.
Featured Video
How to Install Cable Rail Around Wood-Post CornersHighlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
I have the m111-fs. I haven't had a staple stuck in it yet. It has about 4500 square feet under it. Not a ton of flooring, but there still isn't a scratch on it. I love the pre-finished flooring foot. I can usually get about 30% more done it a day because of it since I don't have to keep picking it up and moving it. You just roll it along.
As a side benefit - the finish foot also keeps the stapler a lot more stable, no worries about it tipping and damaging the floor.JT
Definitely. And upgrading from a manual nailer, you'll wonder how you ever got by.
I purchased the air powered Porta Nails model "Porta A Matic Nailer 421" I laid 2,000 sq ft of red oak. A really great machine, no jambs. I used the 2 " "T" nails, about 15,000 nails.
Virginbuild
Hand nailing in my youth,I was able to lay 360' of 2" hardwood flooring,3¼ would have been much more,figure it out,it's easy enough.You young guys have got it too easy heh heh.
youre off topic lol
You can't go wong w/ either, but I hear the prefin./ foot setup is the sh*t. For hard (brittle ) species wood, you'll need nails. The staples are ALOT cheaper though. I have a Bostich air nailer & an Ebay brand stapler. They BOTH work great. You don't need a huge compressor. I have a Porter Cable "job boss". Big mistake unless you run 4 guns every day. Hope this helps.
Edited 8/28/2009 7:58 pm ET by NYFLOORGUY
I have 670 sq ft of soild 5/8 bamboo that looks similar to psl beams and was thinking that a nail would split the flooring. I am kind of stuck here, I have always had great luck with the Porta-nailer but I am done swinging that mallet 3 times as much as needed.
I had mine set on two hits,at the end of the day you knew you had been working.Still it was better than lookin at a busted thumb after hitting it with a 24oz hammer!
Regards,mack.
Saw a guy on TV a few years back, he designed and installed custom medallions in hardwood. 6' diameter geometric paterns, coat of arms, that kind of thing.
First he would lay the hardwood, pre-drilled and handnailed. Then they would sand the floor. The circle or whatever shape he needed to inlay the medallion was cut with a router.
IIRC, he was charging around $50k for a foyer.
The first guy I layed hardwood for had us do it the same way, pre-drill and handnail. I don't know if I'd like to try that again, I was a lot better with a hammer 30 yrs ago.
Pre drilled? Guess I never heard of that. I used to hand nail with the cut nails some years ago. The squared off ends used to push the wood through and not split it. I would set the nail with the head of the next nail. I know, that was old school, but I was taught that by a guy who was in his late 60's back in '78. You knew you had done a days work, especially your poor hands.
When I first tried a manual floor nailer, I thought I had died and gone to heaven.
I don't do that many floors anymore, but I have the Bostitch stapler. It's a wonder.
I pre-drill and hand nail a decent amount around the edges, but part of the benefit of using a flooring nailer is the mallet knocks the boards tight while driving the nail/staple. It's not as important with site finished flooring because it's grouted before finishing, but getting a whole load of pre-finished flooring that is straight as an arrow is almost impossible. there are always a few hockey sticks.