The latest buzz is to restore your nice period windows rather than replacing them. After researching the replacement option and the restoration option (FHB Feb/Mar 2004 David Gibney) (NYT Home section July 28, 2011), I have decided to restore since I can’t find anything on the market short of a complete custom job that comes anywhere close to the beauty of these 100 year old windows in my house in Yonkers. Even if it takes me the rest of the summer, I will still be ahead of the game – i am retired and a pretty decent amateur woodworker. Photos are posted. At least the hardware is in semi-decent shape. The corner of my window is in even worse shape than the one in the FHB article referenced above. How should I tackle this job?
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story

Freestanding with boxed stairs, this small deck is full of ideas for a long-lasting entry that will look great for years to come.
Highlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Fine Homebuilding Magazine
- Home Group
- Antique Trader
- Arts & Crafts Homes
- Bank Note Reporter
- Cabin Life
- Cuisine at Home
- Fine Gardening
- Fine Woodworking
- Green Building Advisor
- Garden Gate
- Horticulture
- Keep Craft Alive
- Log Home Living
- Military Trader/Vehicles
- Numismatic News
- Numismaster
- Old Cars Weekly
- Old House Journal
- Period Homes
- Popular Woodworking
- Script
- ShopNotes
- Sports Collectors Digest
- Threads
- Timber Home Living
- Traditional Building
- Woodsmith
- World Coin News
- Writer's Digest
Replies
Obviously you're going to remove all the rotten wood first by any means possible. Go to http://www.abatron.com/ and get the Liquidwood and WoodEpox kit. I've used these products for 20 years and never had a problem. You'l have to do a bit of shaping and sanding but your window will look like new when you're done. make sure to come back and post some "after" pictures when you're finished.
wood restoration kit.
There is quite a bit of stress in the corner of that sash when the window is opened and closed. i am not sure that type of product will withstand it.. I was thinking of using the dutchman method to repair it.
quite a bit of stress.........
The final fit and finish should remedy that. Part of the reno process on moving parts is getting the operable fit taken care of as well.
Whatever fix you use, take the time to restore the opening and closing to it's original condition. Most of the stress in a window like that should be taken up by the hinges and closing mechanism.
And of course the most important fix-find what did in the window in the first place and take care of that. End grain wicks up water and newer woods available wick it even faster. Limit water intrusion and seal all open grain real well.
Best of luck.
It will take the stress just fine assuming you prepped the old wood properly. The WoodEpox is much stronger than the wood itself.
Bigalb we can see from the pictures that one sash on the right is badly rotted. It looks like the top of the left isn't in very good shape, nor is the top jamb. I don't know how many windows you have that need to be fixed. The one shown is under a porch roof, from the look of it. I can't really tell but my first question is, where is the water coming from that has rotted the window. Could there be a dormer above or a place the porch roof intersects a wall or other roof. First thing to do is find and correct this problem.
Looks like your sash are bad and I would recommend replacing them and not trying to do a patch of some sort. There is a chance the window jambs may also need attention. You may be able to use a traditional, divided light, wood sash. You might want to consider buying a ready made one rather than making one. Brockway Smith Co. (Brosco) is a New England distributer of traditional wood sash. They have some for casement windows and a pair of those may fit. You would still have to repair the jambs, mount the hardware, perhaps do some fitting and make an astrigal where they meet. I think you are beyond a dutchman or other patch.
http://www.broscobookofdesigns.com/bod/bod2010?folio=b366#pg386
window restoration
Actually, aside from the corner of the sash in question, the rest of the sash and the other sash are in pretty decent shape. When we purchased this house 28 years ago, there were french doors leading out to a porch off of the living room. However the porch was nowhere to be found, having been removed at some point in the past which would have exposed the window to the elements with no protection of any kind. I rebuilt the porch and never did anything about the window which was in approximately the same shape as you see it now. So i think I am going to attempt to do a repair. Thank you for the input however. it is much appreciated.
If you're really interested in restoring them (and you can't find replacements), I'd suggest that you set up your router table (or, if you have a planer, get blades made) and manufacture new stock for the worst pieces, vs trying to patch them piecemeal.