Building new home with radiant tube in basement slab and first floor.Insulating r40 ceilings and r28 walls .Yes this is from the “great white north”.Looking a tfuel type to fire the boiler.Choices I have oil,propane or electric. Which fuel would be the most efficient given water temps in tube do not have to be super hot.
Discussion Forum
Discussion Forum
Up Next
Video Shorts
Featured Story
![](https://images.finehomebuilding.com/app/uploads/2024/08/23064822/Larrys-Wall-Construction-thumb-16x9.jpg)
Listeners write in about opera and keeping young by building and ask questions about leaky light fixtures, porch conversions, and installing wood siding.
Featured Video
SawStop's Portable Tablesaw is Bigger and Better Than BeforeHighlights
"I have learned so much thanks to the searchable articles on the FHB website. I can confidently say that I expect to be a life-long subscriber." - M.K.
Replies
Do you care about effiency or about operating cost?
You really need to find out the price of your different fuels and then adjust for the eff of the boiler.
Thanks Bill , Bruce
The efficiency of the boiler (with exception of electric) will depend on the design of the boiler, not the fuel. For natural gas/lp for instance, you can buy a boiler that is 80% efficient or one that is 97% efficient.
If I were faced with the decision, this is how I would evaluate what I would buy. Find out availability and cost of the fuels you have available. Determine a gross BTU/$$ for each type. Then look at the costs of various boilers that use the least expensive fuel.
If it cost $1000/year to heat with a boiler that cost $10,000 and it costs $1500/year to heat with a boiler that costs $5,000, then the (simplistic) "break-even" point is 10 years.
Any payback of ten years or less is a reasonably good investment, if you plan to live there that long. If the payback is over 15 years, don't do it.
Check out the January, 1987 issue of JLC.
Comparing Energy Costs
Very useful cost chart in there comparing various efficiencies and fuels.
Wood, electric, fuel oil, nat gas & LP.
did you say 1987 ?
carpenter in transition
Yup.Got it open in front of me right now.If you've got the discs, use search = comparing energy costsThe comparison prices on this chart include costs encompassing a range of prices that include today and a ways out in the future, as well. However, the efficiences of the heating appliances on the chart only go out to 85% for fossil fuels. But the comparison per BTU yield to current pricing would still be valid and a little math should render a valid figure of actual cost for today's higher efficiency appliances.Knowledge is power, but only if applied in a timely fashion.
Edited 1/27/2005 12:40 pm ET by GOLDHILLER
Around here, oil would win hands down. Not for ultimate combustion efficiency, but for cost of operation.
The advantage with propane is that you could run a modulating condensing boiler with variable output temperatures on full reset, achieving amazing operating efficiency.
There are new condensing oil boilers available, and more to come. Many are on the market in Europe.
This one is interesting:
http://www.houseneeds.com/shop/HeatingProducts/boilers/monitor/monitorboilersoilfcx.htm
Thanks I will investigate this option.
Big johnson