Spray Foam: What Do You Really Know?
To get the full benefit of this super-insulation, you must understand the difference between open- and closed-cell foams, how they perform, and how they’re installed.
Synopsis: You might know that spray-foam insulation is an increasingly popular alternative for insulation, and it’s an effective air barrier to boot. But if you decide to insulate your house with spray foam, which type do you choose: open cell or closed cell? What differentiates one from the other? Is one greener than the other? Which is easier to install? In this article, FHB associate editor Rob Yagid explores spray-foam insulation: its composition, its installation, its best uses, and its cost. This article also includes a sidebar with comments from building-science experts Bruce Harley and Peter Pfeiffer, who explain how they prefer to use spray-foam insulation. Additional sidebars explore eco-conscious spray-foam choices, retrofitting with spray foam, and sources for spray foam.
I recently spent a day pulling wire with a friend who’s an electrician in New York. Late in the afternoon, our conversation turned to a client and friend of his who was seeking advice about insulating her new home. The topic caught the interest of some other guys on site, most from different trades, who gathered around and offered their opinions on which material she should use. After a brief debate, everyone seemed confident that spray foam would yield the best performance. That was until I threw out the question, “Which type?” Sure, they all knew there were two types of spray polyurethane foam, open cell and closed cell, but no one knew enough about them to step up and defend the use of one over the other. The truth is, neither did I.
Spray polyurethane-foam manufacturers have a relatively easy job when it comes to marketing their products because of one key statistic. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, 30% or more of a home’s heating and cooling costs are attributed to air leakage. Spray polyurethane foam, or spray foam as it’s most often called, is an effective air barrier and significantly reduces energy loss. Combined with a higher thermal resistance (R-value) than most other forms of insulation, it’s no wonder spray foam is often relied on to help make houses ultra efficient. Simply choosing to insulate your home with spray foam doesn’t guarantee that it’ll perform to its full potential, though. Different climates, construction practices, and wall and roof assemblies benefit from different types of foam. Building codes require specific thicknesses, and proper installation is a must.
It won’t settle and it doesn’t off-gas toxic chemicals
Because of the urea-formaldehyde foam used to insulate homes in the 1970s, which could degrade and off-gas unsafe formaldehyde, spray foam is often perceived as being unhealthful and poorly performing. Installers that look as if they’re outfitted to survive a nuclear catastrophe perpetuate the misconception that spray foam is toxic.
The fact is that when it’s installed properly, spray foam is more physically stable than the studs and sheathing it’s adhered to. The oxygen-supplied respirators and head-to-toe protective suits installers wear are necessary only to keep the chemicals that make up spray foam out of their lungs and off their skin during installation.
Spray foam is made of a two-part mixture. The A part is isocyanate, a petroleum-based chemical made by only a handful of companies in the world. The B part contains a catalyst, polyol resin, a surfactant, and a blowing agent. Some manufacturers add flame retardants and colorants to their B component as well.
The blowing agent, a gas that expands the foam’s cells to give it volume, receives a lot of scrutiny. Over time, from three months to a year, a portion of the blowing agent in closed-cell foam evaporates into the air. Prior to 2003, chlorofluorocarbon and hydrochlorofluorocarbon blowing agents were in widespread use. These gases are damaging to the atmosphere. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has banned the use of those chemicals and recognized the current hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) blowing agent as a safe alternative.
For more photos, drawings, and details, click the View PDF button below:
Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products
Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.
Great Stuff Foam Cleaner
Respirator Mask
Disposable Suit
